Why was Stuart England seen as a 'failed state' by its European counterparts?
One argument that attracted particular attention in my recent book, Devil-Land: England Under Siege 1588-1688, was the claim that "to contemporaries and foreigners alike, 17th century England was a failed state: a discomfiting byword for seditious rebellion, religious extremism and regime change." It was part of the book's emphasis on Stuart England's characteristic insecurity, instability and vulnerability, which is also reflected in its title. The nickname ‘Duyvel-Landt’, or ‘Devil-Land’ was applied to mid-17th century England by an anonymous Dutch pamphleteer in 1652, who had been outraged by the English Parliament’s decision to put on trial and publicly execute its divinely ordained king, Charles I, while the successor republican regime seemed to declare war on the Dutch Republic as commercial rivals.
In this context, it was a deliberately polemical and provocative claim, and anachronistic or insensitive parallels with current affairs are unhelpful. Today, there are clear metrics and databased policy tools deployed to measure ‘failed states’. But, in 1652, when that Dutch pamphleteer described England as ‘Devil-Land’, the country had been bitterly divided by civil war for over a decade; brothers had taken up arms against one another for either King or Parliament; countless wartime atrocities had occurred, including premeditated massacres; and, in Ireland, extensive ethnic cleansing had occurred. After Charles I’s regicide in January 1649, England underwent no less than five major regime changes in a decade with more minor revolutions and constitutional experiments before Charles II was restored in 1660.
This story is from the Issue 132 edition of All About History UK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the Issue 132 edition of All About History UK.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 8,500+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Greatest Battles - BATTLE OF SHIROYAMA
KAGOSHIMA, JAPAN, 1-24 SEPTEMBER 1877
WOMEN IN COMPUTING
From Ada Lovelace to the codebreakers of WWII, John Croucher discusses the role of women in computing
"IT'S IMPORTANT THAT BLIND AND VISUALLY IMPAIRED PEOPLE OWN OUR OWN HISTORY"
Blindness and blind people have usually been framed in history as inspirational or tragic, but now Selina Mills wants to question that narrative
Bess of Hardwick ELIZABETH'S NEMESIS
Who was the ambitious Tudor noblewoman who proved to be a thorn in Gloriana’s side?
THE GOLDEN AGE OF SMUGGLING
Discover the age when the coasts of Britain were awash with illegal goods
What's in a name?
20 strangest royal nicknames from history (and where they came from)
GODS OF EGYPT
Discover how ancient Egyptians explained the mysteries of the world
OPPENHEIMER
Christopher Nolan's latest history-themed blockbuster is an artistic triumph
JAPAN HAD REMAINED ISOLATIONIST?
While Japan keeps its distance, overall supremacy of the region could be up for grabs
BATTLE OF SHIPKA PASS
SHIPKA, BULGARIA, JULY 1877-JANUARY 1878