THE WHO, WHAT, WHERE AND HOW OF 'WHY'
Record Collector|January 2023
The song Why has a significant place in music history because it was one of the tracks the fledgling Beatles recorded with Tony Sheridan in 1961 before making a recording debut in their own right. But few people know of an earlier, 1958 recording of the song made by Sheridan, which recently surfaced on a 10" acetate. Beatles scholar Hans Olof Gottfridsson tells the story of a song that would later attain immortality by association.
Hans Olof Gottfridsson
THE WHO, WHAT, WHERE AND HOW OF 'WHY'

The Tony Sheridan and Bill (William) Crompton-penned song Why (Can't You Love Me Again?) is one of two original compositions that Tony Sheridan and The Beatles recorded for Polydor and Bert Kaempfert in Hamburg, Germany, before The Beatles made their proper record debut for Parlophone back home in the UK in October 1962. (The other was the instrumental Cry For A Shadow, written by John Lennon and George Harrison, and recorded by The Beatles without Sheridan.)

What is considerably less known is that Tony Sheridan also made a private demo recording of the same song back in 1958. This recording was long believed to have been lost forever, but against all odds it was rediscovered by chance a few years ago at a car boot sale in Studley, South Warwickshire, England. Of course it reappeared with a scratch or two, as you would expect after decades on the road, but it was in good condition overall and still fully playable.

This article tells the full story for the first time of Sheridan's 1958 recording of Why and the demo record he made at the time.

The article also presents three unique discs containing the Sheridan/Beatles recording of the song from 1961. In addition, the largely unknown story of Sheridan and Crompton's songwriting partnership is told and a second song that may have been written by them - or possibly by Shakespeare (!) - has been unearthed from the archives.

هذه القصة مأخوذة من طبعة January 2023 من Record Collector.

ابدأ النسخة التجريبية المجانية من Magzter GOLD لمدة 7 أيام للوصول إلى آلاف القصص المتميزة المنسقة وأكثر من 9,000 مجلة وصحيفة.

هذه القصة مأخوذة من طبعة January 2023 من Record Collector.

ابدأ النسخة التجريبية المجانية من Magzter GOLD لمدة 7 أيام للوصول إلى آلاف القصص المتميزة المنسقة وأكثر من 9,000 مجلة وصحيفة.

المزيد من القصص من RECORD COLLECTOR مشاهدة الكل
Paperback Blighters - The books every record collector should read.
Record Collector

Paperback Blighters - The books every record collector should read.

The books every record collector should read. Vinyl, you may have heard, has made a big comeback. In 2022, sales of vinyl albums surpassed compact discs (CDs) for the first time in more than three decades in terms of global revenue, racking up more than $1.2bn.

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 2024
"Beware the Savage Lure/of 1984..." - David Bowie is one of the most venerated musicians ever. But even he had his bad periods.
Record Collector

"Beware the Savage Lure/of 1984..." - David Bowie is one of the most venerated musicians ever. But even he had his bad periods.

David Bowie is one of the most venerated musicians ever. But even he had his bad periods. For many, 1984 remains the nadir of his Phil Collins” phase; an artistic/sartonial/tonsorial disaster area. But was it really that awful? Forty years on, Matt Phillips explores Bowie's so-called annus horribilis.

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 2024
7"  Heaven & Hell the Story of the 45 - The 45 turns 75 this year. Matthew Quinlan charts its history, recalling the RPM wars and two belligerent titans who went into battle over the speed of spinning sound
Record Collector

7" Heaven & Hell the Story of the 45 - The 45 turns 75 this year. Matthew Quinlan charts its history, recalling the RPM wars and two belligerent titans who went into battle over the speed of spinning sound

Someone needs to come and empty the bins behind the Lloyds Bank branch in Kingston-upon-Thames. It’s been raining and flattened cardboard slumps next to a flytipped air conditioning unit and a rusting clothes rack. There are two signs at head height on the red brick wall. One warns that you’ll be clamped if you park here; the other, a stainless-steel plaque, marks Nipper’s 100th birthday. Nipper, the dog at the heart of the HMV and RCA Victor logos, was a white terrier with chocolate brown ears, maybe a Jack Russell, Smooth Fox, or Bull Terrier, more likely a mix. This is his final resting place. He was buried under a mulberry tree but, you know, urban sprawl, progress, etc. The plaque was unveiled by the Chairman of HMV Stores on 15 August 1984, while Captain Sensible, Janice Long, and a Nipper doppelganger looked on. Round the corner, at HMV and Our Price, George Michael’s Careless Whisper was flying off the shelves, and every copy turned at 45 RPM.

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 2024
STARS ON 45s
Record Collector

STARS ON 45s

A BUNCH OF MUSICIANS - 45, COUNT 'EM! RHAPSODISE ABOUT THEIR FAVOURITE SINGLE

time-read
1 min  |
September 2024
THE TORTURED SHOPPER'S DEPARTMENT
Record Collector

THE TORTURED SHOPPER'S DEPARTMENT

John Coleman celebrates the great art of vinyl collecting on the 45th Anniversary of Record Collector and finds out, in an exhausting series of anxietyinducing sprees, how much vinyl you can buy today, ina variety of outlets, with 45.

time-read
2 mins  |
September 2024
Young American
Record Collector

Young American

A serendipitous collaboration with David Bowie in 1974 kick-started Luther Vandross' recording career. But he still faced an uphill struggle to succeed as a solo artist. Charles Waring talks to some of the singer's most trusted collaborators about his early years and how he battled to be heard....

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 2024
MOD ALMIGHTY
Record Collector

MOD ALMIGHTY

Steve Ellis began his career as a mod in flower-power clobber as frontman of chart-toppers Love Affair. Quitting in 1970, he worked with The Who's Roger Daltrey then gave up music to become a docker before a near-death experience. Interest in his work was rekindled after hooking up with long-time fan Paul Weller. Lois Wilson hears how his romance with music endures.

time-read
7 mins  |
September 2024
ANARCHISTS IN THE UK
Record Collector

ANARCHISTS IN THE UK

EXACTLY 45 YEARS AGO, CRASS, THE ANARCHIST ACTIVIST COLLECTIVE, WERE FINISHING PIVOTAL SECOND ALBUM, STATIONS OF THE CRASS.

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 2024
The boy with the thorn in his side
Record Collector

The boy with the thorn in his side

David Cassidy was arguably the biggest solo star of the immediate post-Beatles era, yet his fame as well as his boyish good looks and extracurricular excessesovershadow the excellence of his breathily intimate, musically accomplished records. Simon Goddard, RC contributor and author of an acclaimed series of books on David Bowie, hails the work of the tortured pop idol

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 2024
"I COULD JUST THROW MUD AT THE WALL"
Record Collector

"I COULD JUST THROW MUD AT THE WALL"

There's little sign of slowing down from the 19-year-old Pete Townshend. Currently on the go: multi-media project The Age Of Anxiety; a dance production of Quadrophenia; and Pete Townshend Live In Concert 1985-2001, a 14-disc boxset of his solo in-concert recordings. Not, he admits, that his every whim and fancy are worth deeper exploration. \"Some of them are good ideas, some of them are pretty dumb,\"

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 2024