Learning from our mistakes
New Zealand Listener|September 09-15 2023
Cleared of murder, Alan Hall has just been awarded $5 million in compensation for wrongful conviction. But Phil Taylor argues flaws in the justice system remain unaddressed.
Learning from our mistakes

Today, it's a no-brainer that Alan Hall was wrongfully convicted of the 1985 murder of Arthur Easton and of wounding his son Brendan. Why it took so long and whether we will pause to learn the inherent lessons are important questions.

The prosecution case had multiple problems, the most alarming being changes to an eyewitness's statement without his knowledge. In its unaltered form, the statement would have meant Hall, a Pākehā, could not have been the man the witness saw the night Easton died of stab wounds in his Papakura home.

In the altered version, the witness's emphatic description of the offender as Māori was removed and an assertion was added that the witness had identified a sweatshirt from Hall's home as the one worn by the man he saw, when the witness had not been shown it. All other evidence that might have alerted the defence to these prejudicial changes was concealed.

In its judgment quashing Hall's convictions, the Supreme Court said, "The crown accepts that such departures from accepted standards must either be the result of extreme incompetence or of a deliberate and wrongful strategy to secure conviction." As well as a renewed homicide investigation and an Independent Police Conduct Authority inquiry, police are looking into the deception at the heart of this miscarriage of justice.

Hall was denied justice by a series of failings following his wrongful conviction. For cases like his, getting to the point of exoneration is often frustrating and almost always exhausting. It can take years, sometimes decades. Then, when we get there, too often we are content to learn very little.

هذه القصة مأخوذة من طبعة September 09-15 2023 من New Zealand Listener.

ابدأ النسخة التجريبية المجانية من Magzter GOLD لمدة 7 أيام للوصول إلى آلاف القصص المتميزة المنسقة وأكثر من 9,000 مجلة وصحيفة.

هذه القصة مأخوذة من طبعة September 09-15 2023 من New Zealand Listener.

ابدأ النسخة التجريبية المجانية من Magzter GOLD لمدة 7 أيام للوصول إلى آلاف القصص المتميزة المنسقة وأكثر من 9,000 مجلة وصحيفة.

المزيد من القصص من NEW ZEALAND LISTENER مشاهدة الكل
First-world problem
New Zealand Listener

First-world problem

Harrowing tales of migrants attempting to enter the US highlight the political failure to fully tackle the problem.

time-read
3 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Applying intelligence to AI
New Zealand Listener

Applying intelligence to AI

I call it the 'Terminator Effect', based on the premise that thinking machines took over the world.

time-read
2 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Nazism rears its head
New Zealand Listener

Nazism rears its head

Smirky Höcke, with his penchant for waving with a suspiciously straight elbow and an open palm, won't get to be boss of either state.

time-read
2 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Staying ahead of the game
New Zealand Listener

Staying ahead of the game

Will the brave new world of bipartisanship that seems to be on offer with an Infrastructure Commission come to fruition?

time-read
4 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Grasping the nettle
New Zealand Listener

Grasping the nettle

Broccoli is horrible. It smells, when being cooked, like cat pee.

time-read
3 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Hangry? Eat breakfast
New Zealand Listener

Hangry? Eat breakfast

People who don't break their fast first thing in the morning report the least life satisfaction.

time-read
3 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Chemical reaction
New Zealand Listener

Chemical reaction

Nitrates in processed meats are well known to cause harm, but consumed from plant sources, their effect is quite different.

time-read
4 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Me and my guitar
New Zealand Listener

Me and my guitar

Australian guitarist Karin Schaupp sticks to the familiar for her Dunedin concerts.

time-read
2 mins  |
September 9, 2024
Time is on my side
New Zealand Listener

Time is on my side

Age does not weary some of our much-loved musicians but what keeps them on the road?

time-read
7 mins  |
September 9, 2024
The kids are not alright
New Zealand Listener

The kids are not alright

Nuanced account details how China's blessed generation has been replaced by one consumed by fear and hopelessness.

time-read
4 mins  |
September 9, 2024