All Maps Are Wrong But Many Are Useful
Muse Science Magazine for Kids|May - June 2019

It is an inarguable mathematical fact that every map is a lie.

Evelyn Lamb
All Maps Are Wrong But Many Are Useful

Well, a map is not a lie in the sense of a statement intended to deceive someone. Maps do give us useful information about the world. But every map is a compromise. Statistician George Box famously said, “All models are wrong.” He was pointing out that no simplified mathematical formulation can perfectly capture the complicated reality of the world. He followed it up, though, with, “But some are useful.” Even models that are incomplete can help us understand the world, as long as we understand their strengths and limitations. The same is true of maps.

Mathematical Impossibility

In the 1820s, German mathematician Carl Friedrich Gauss proved the theorema egregium, which is Latin for “remarkable theorem.” (A theorem is a mathematical statement that can be proved using a chain of logical reasoning that starts with some basic assumptions.) One consequence of this theorem is the fact that there is no way to draw a flat map of the spherical Earth without some distortions. Of course, if you’ve ever peeled an orange or clementine and tried to press the peel completely flat, you might have figured that out already. It always tears somewhere.

Mathematical impossibility is no match for the convenience of a flat representation of the world, though. Geography textbooks and magazine pages just can’t accommodate tiny globes. So until virtual reality, holographic, or replication technology improves significantly and we can have accurate globes at our fingertips whenever we want, humans will keep drawing 2D maps despite Gauss’s theorem.

Compromise, Compromise, Compromise

Some maps distort area, some distort shapes, some distort directions and distances. Different situations call for maps with different strengths. For hundreds of years, cartographers have been creating maps that work the best for particular situations.

Diese Geschichte stammt aus der May - June 2019-Ausgabe von Muse Science Magazine for Kids.

Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.

Diese Geschichte stammt aus der May - June 2019-Ausgabe von Muse Science Magazine for Kids.

Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.

WEITERE ARTIKEL AUS MUSE SCIENCE MAGAZINE FOR KIDSAlle anzeigen
A Mars Rock Found With Leopard Spots Could Be a Sign of Ancient Life
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

A Mars Rock Found With Leopard Spots Could Be a Sign of Ancient Life

IN JULY, NASA'S PERSEVERANCE ROVER CAME ACROSS A SPOTTED ROCK IN WHAT WAS ONCE A RIVERBED IN THE JEZERO CRATER ON MARS.

time-read
1 min  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind
Para Athlete Uses Exoskeleton Suit to Carry the Olympic Torch
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

Para Athlete Uses Exoskeleton Suit to Carry the Olympic Torch

In July, a 36-year-old French tennis para athlete, Kevin Piette, got a chance to participate in this summer’s Olympic torch relay without using a wheelchair.

time-read
1 min  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind
Ancient Egyptians May Have Used a Water System to Lift Stones to Build Pyramid
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

Ancient Egyptians May Have Used a Water System to Lift Stones to Build Pyramid

HOW ANCIENT EGYPTIANS BUILT THE MASSIVE PYRAMIDS IN EGYPT MORE THAN 4,000 YEARS AGO HAS LONG BEEN A TOPIC OF WONDER AND DEBATE.

time-read
1 min  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind
Seals Can Make Big Dives Thanks to Their Big Hearts
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

Seals Can Make Big Dives Thanks to Their Big Hearts

SEALS AND SEA LIONS, WHICH ARE SEMI-AQUATIC MAMMALS, CAN HOLD THEIR BREATHS UNDERWATER FOR ESPECIALLY LONG PERIODS OF TIME.

time-read
1 min  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind
THE BIG-CITY LIFE OF STEVEN J.BIKE SHOP RABBIT IN BROOKLYN, NEW YORK
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

THE BIG-CITY LIFE OF STEVEN J.BIKE SHOP RABBIT IN BROOKLYN, NEW YORK

Bicycle Roots is a full-service bike shop. It's in the heart of Brooklyn, New York. Joe Lawler is the co-owner and service manager. Perhaps more important, he's \"dad\" to the shop's most popular employee. That's Steven J. Lawler.

time-read
1 min  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind
Wild Ones
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

Wild Ones

WHAT FACTORS DRIVE PEOPLE TO BUY MONKEYS, TIGERS, AND OTHER WILD ANIMALS?

time-read
3 Minuten  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind
HOW TO CONQUER THE WORLD
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

HOW TO CONQUER THE WORLD

A brief history

time-read
4 Minuten  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind
What would happen if meteors hit Earth?
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

What would happen if meteors hit Earth?

You may have seen Ameteors fly into Earth's atmosphere, in the form of shooting stars.

time-read
2 Minuten  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind
WORKING WORMS
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

WORKING WORMS

DON'T JUST THROW THOSE TABLE SCRAPS AWAY! LET A BOX OF WORMS TURN THEM INTO SOMETHING USEFUL.

time-read
5 Minuten  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind
Dog Rescue Saves Lives
Muse Science Magazine for Kids

Dog Rescue Saves Lives

THE ARGUMENT FOR ADOPTING A NO-KILL GOAL

time-read
4 Minuten  |
Muse November-December 2024: Pets on the Mind