Thinking Out Of The Witness Box
Outlook|September 26, 2016

Mahmood Farooqui’s rape conviction for forced oral sex opens a hectic debate about the ‘lacunae’ in the amended criminal law

Pragya Singh
Thinking Out Of The Witness Box

Like the plot of Pipli (Live), occasionally a story becomes so big that everyone descends upon it. The irony is, ever since Pipli’s director Mahmood Farooqui was held for raping an American scholar, there has been a great deal of debate on the nature of his assault and, after the verdict, on the quantum of punishment.

Feminists and legal luminaries have weighed in, and while all agree that anyone accused of rape needs to be punished, how the law defines and punishes the crime is being contested. Further, the debate has split the women’s movement on other asp­ects of criminal law, as amended in 2013.

To be sure, Farooqui isn’t the first well­ placed man charged with rape and at the centre of a controversy. When Tarun Tejpal, founder­ editor of Tehelka, faced similar charges, a polarising disputation erupted over whether what he did was ‘rape’.

“Indeed, feminists are debating these issues, but the women’s movement always had spirited discussions. It’s a very healthy trend,” says feminist writer Urvashi Butalia.

That said, participants are cautious. Critics fear being misunderstood and painted anti­woman. Those who spearheaded the anti­rape law reform in 2013 worry about ‘red herrings’ and dilution of rights. “Nobody is closing the door to discussion.

I object only to how lacunae in the law are being brought up after high­profile men are found guilty of rape,” says senior Supreme Court lawyer Rebecca John.

“Critique of the judgement has been misread by some as a call for trivialising forced oral sex as a minor indiscretion, or a misog­ynist reversal of battles hard won. Why it should be so is puzzling. Have we not critiqued judgements earlier,” asks Manisha Sethi, who teaches at Jamia Millia Islamia.

Diese Geschichte stammt aus der September 26, 2016-Ausgabe von Outlook.

Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.

Diese Geschichte stammt aus der September 26, 2016-Ausgabe von Outlook.

Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.

WEITERE ARTIKEL AUS OUTLOOKAlle anzeigen
Layers Of Lear
Outlook

Layers Of Lear

Director Rajat Kapoor and actor Vinay Pathak's ode to Shakespeare is an experience to behold

time-read
4 Minuten  |
December 21, 2024
Loss and Longing
Outlook

Loss and Longing

Memories can be painful, but they also make life more meaningful

time-read
6 Minuten  |
December 21, 2024
Suprabhatham Sub Judice
Outlook

Suprabhatham Sub Judice

M.S. Subbulakshmi decided the fate of her memorials a long time ago

time-read
8 Minuten  |
December 21, 2024
Fortress of Desire
Outlook

Fortress of Desire

A performance titled 'A Streetcart Named Desire', featuring Indian and international artists and performers, explored different desires through an unusual act on a full moon night at the Gwalior Fort

time-read
7 Minuten  |
December 21, 2024
Of Hope and Hopelessness
Outlook

Of Hope and Hopelessness

The body appears as light in Payal Kapadia's film

time-read
3 Minuten  |
December 21, 2024
Ruptured Lives
Outlook

Ruptured Lives

A visit to Bangladesh in 2010 shaped the author's novel, a sensitively sketched tale of migrants' struggles

time-read
5 Minuten  |
December 21, 2024
The Big Book
Outlook

The Big Book

The Big Book of Odia Literature is a groundbreaking work that provides readers with a comprehensive introduction to the rich and varied literary traditions of Odisha

time-read
4 Minuten  |
December 21, 2024
How to Refuse the Generous Thief
Outlook

How to Refuse the Generous Thief

The poet uses all the available arsenal in English to write the most anti-colonial poetry

time-read
4 Minuten  |
December 21, 2024
The Freedom Compartment
Outlook

The Freedom Compartment

#traindiaries is a photo journal shot in the ladies coaches of Mumbai locals. It explores how women engage and familiarise themselves with spaces by building relationships with complete strangers

time-read
1 min  |
December 21, 2024
Love, Up in the Clouds
Outlook

Love, Up in the Clouds

Manikbabur Megh is an unusual love story about a man falling for a cloud. Amborish Roychoudhury discusses the process of Manikbabu's creation with actor Chandan Sen and director Abhinandan Banerjee

time-read
5 Minuten  |
December 21, 2024