Unmindful of the price he has to pay, Justice Karnan continues the fight against his brother judges The Week brings to you what is on the maverick judge's mind
About three weeks ago, I rang up Justice Chinnaswamy Swaminathan Karnan, sitting judge of the Calcutta High Court, requesting an interview. “I am out of station now. I will consider whether to give you an interview or not after I return,” he replied.
Justice Karnan has been engaged in a bitter legal battle with the Supreme Court. A seven-member Constitution Bench of the apex court on February 8, 2017 stripped him of all his judicial powers and asked for an explanation about the allegations of corruption he raised against judges of the Supreme Court and the Madras High Court. Justice Karnan retaliated by issuing a contempt notice to the seven judges. Subsequently, the Supreme Court ordered Justice Karnan to be medically examined to know whether he was “feigning mental imbalance” and submit the report by May 8. Within hours of the order, Justice Karnan asked the Delhi Police to get the seven judges examined by a psychiatric board.
Is he insane? I wondered. But he seemed perfectly all right when I talked to him over the phone. I again called him up for the appointment. This time, the judge burst into laughter. “Why would you like to interview me? The Supreme Court thinks I have lost my mental balance,” he said.
“Your lordship, I would like to see for myself,” I replied.
Justice Karnan handed over the phone to his secretary and I got an appointment for May 4, the same day the medical team mandated by the Supreme Court was scheduled to examine him. When I reached his sprawling apartment in the plush New Town area of Kolkata, which also functions as his makeshift office, a large media contingent was already present. I saw Justice Karnan in the corridor, dressed in a white shirt and dhoti, looking a little tense.
“Do you know where are the doctors and the police team accompanying them?” asked Justice Karnan.
Diese Geschichte stammt aus der May 21, 2017-Ausgabe von THE WEEK.
Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.
Bereits Abonnent ? Anmelden
Diese Geschichte stammt aus der May 21, 2017-Ausgabe von THE WEEK.
Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.
Bereits Abonnent? Anmelden
Themes Of Choice
As Savvy Investors Seek New Avenues, Thematic Mutual Funds Are Gaining Popularity
A golden girl
One of India's most formidable beauties passed away earlier this month. The odd thing is she would absolutely hate this obituary; she hated being written about and avoided publicity for all of her nine decades. Indira Aswani was 93 when she died. But anyone who encountered her, even briefly, was in such awe of her grace and poise, and one could not but remember her forever.
The interest in wine is growing delightfully in India
The renowned British wine writer and television presenter Jancis Robinson, 74, recently came to Delhi and Mumbai to reacquaint herself with India's wine industry. This was the Robinson's fourth visit to India; the last one was seven years ago. On this trip, Robinson and her husband, restaurateur Nicholas Lander, were hosted by the Taj Hotels and Sonal Holland, India's only Master of Wine.
United in the states
Indian-Americans coming together under the Democratic umbrella could get Harris over the line in key battlegrounds
COVER DRIVE
Usage-driven motor insurance policies offer several benefits
GDP as the only measure of progress is illogical
Dasho Karma Ura, one of the world's leading happiness experts, has guided Bhutan's unique gross national happiness (GNH) project. He uses empirical data to show that money cannot buy happiness in all circumstances, rather it is family and health that have the strongest positive effect on happiness. Excerpts from an interview:
India is not a controlling big brother
Prime Minister Tshering Tobgay considers India a benevolent elder sibling as the \"big brotherly attitude\" is happily missing from bilateral ties. He thinks the relationship shared by the two countries has become a model of friendship not just for the region, but for the entire world. \"India's attitude is definitely not of a big brother who is controlling and does not allow the little brother to blossom and grow,\" says Tobgay in an exclusive interview with THE WEEK.
Comrade with no foes
Lal Salaam, Comrade Yechury-you were quite a guy!
Pinning down saffron
In her first political bout, Vinesh Phogat rides on the anti-BJP sentiment across Haryana
MAKE IN MANIPUR
Home-made rockets and weapons from across the border are escalating the conflict