Lucy Letby - Police and CPS handling of case adds to concern over convictions
The Guardian|October 11, 2024
When the public inquiry into the crimes of the former nurse Lucy Letby opened in Liverpool last month, its chair, Lady Justice Thirlwall, dismissed concerns about the safety of the convictions as “noise”. The judge cautioned that questions being raised were increasing the distress of parents whose children had died or been harmed.
David Conn Felicity Lawrence
Lucy Letby - Police and CPS handling of case adds to concern over convictions

Letby was found guilty across two trials of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder seven others at the Countess of Chester hospital in 2015 and 2016. Thirlwall pointed out that in May this year, the court of appeal had refused Letby permission to appeal, and she said it was not the role of her inquiry to review the convictions.

Yet questions about the case, and the number of experts raising them, have continued to mount. Letby is being represented by a new barrister, Mark McDonald, and a number of specialists - including leading neonatologists - doctors who specialise in treating premature babies - are voluntarily working with him on an application to the Criminal Cases Review Commission.

Having examined the detail, these experts consider there are more plausible alternative causes of the babies' deaths and collapses than those for which Letby was convicted.

The Guardian can now report on further key concerns about the case, including the approach taken by Cheshire police and the Crown Prosecution Service, and the conduct of the trials.

“The prosecutor's fallacy”

At Letby's first trial, the prosecution used a chart that showed which nurses were on shift when babies were allegedly attacked. The chart was presented to the jury to illustrate the central allegation that Letby was the one constant presence. Its use has prompted unusually vocal criticism from leading statisticians. They argue that the chart represents a classic example of the “prosecutor's fallacy”, in which an investigation starts with only a suspicion, and a case is built to support it, rather than all possible evidence and explanations having been rigorously explored.

Jane Hutton, a professor of statistics at the University of Warwick, said of the shift chart and other elements of the case: “It's a large pile of crockery, much of which is broken. Such a pile does not hold water, however big it is.”

Diese Geschichte stammt aus der October 11, 2024-Ausgabe von The Guardian.

Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.

Diese Geschichte stammt aus der October 11, 2024-Ausgabe von The Guardian.

Starten Sie Ihre 7-tägige kostenlose Testversion von Magzter GOLD, um auf Tausende kuratierte Premium-Storys sowie über 8.000 Zeitschriften und Zeitungen zuzugreifen.

WEITERE ARTIKEL AUS THE GUARDIANAlle anzeigen
Money hacks How to use your Christmas gift vouchers wisely
The Guardian

Money hacks How to use your Christmas gift vouchers wisely

The first thing to do is read the small print (it could be very small if it is squeezed on the back).

time-read
4 Minuten  |
January 04, 2025
'It's not job done' More change to come as M&S gets its spark back
The Guardian

'It's not job done' More change to come as M&S gets its spark back

M&S menswear, above, is starting to compete for style with specialist rivals while the company's menswear has successfully caught the attention of younger buyers

time-read
4 Minuten  |
January 04, 2025
Taken to court ... as a victim of identity theft
The Guardian

Taken to court ... as a victim of identity theft

A fraudulent phone contract has been taken out in my husband's name and he is now threatened with court action.

time-read
1 min  |
January 04, 2025
New start Is 2025 the right time to become your own boss?
The Guardian

New start Is 2025 the right time to become your own boss?

Going freelance is not without risk but if you want to shed the shackles of your 9-5, then Suzanne Bearne can help you plan it properly

time-read
7 Minuten  |
January 04, 2025
Feeling the heat British Gas hit by 400,000 complaints
The Guardian

Feeling the heat British Gas hit by 400,000 complaints

It has been both astonishing and appalling in equal measure,\" says Jonathan Hattersley, 66, from Cambridgeshire.

time-read
3 Minuten  |
January 04, 2025
The Guardian

Biden Blocks Japanese Firm's $15bn Bid for US Steel Over Security Fears

Joe Biden blocked a $14.9bn (£12bn) bid by Japan's Nippon Steel for US Steel yesterday, citing concerns the deal could hurt national security and following through on a pledge to keep the company domestically owned as he prepares to depart the White House.

time-read
1 min  |
January 04, 2025
We're like snipers' Lethal and cheap, drones dominate the frontline now
The Guardian

We're like snipers' Lethal and cheap, drones dominate the frontline now

Denys, a soldier with Ukraine's Khyzhak brigade, describes a new kind of war. Standing in a barracks workshop with piles of basic Ukrainian first-person view (FPV) drones behind him, he says: \"There are fewer gunfights because there are more drone fights.\" Frontlines that were once a gunshot apart are now a killing zone several miles deep as Russian and Ukrainian drone squads hidden behind the frontlines target each other's forces with aerial attacks. \"Back in 2022, we were still running around with machine guns from the tree lines,\" Denys says, almost with nostalgia.

time-read
4 Minuten  |
January 04, 2025
The Guardian

Profits at GB News owner's hedge fund plunge 64%

Profits at the hedge fund co-founded by the GB News and Spectator owner Sir Paul Marshall plunged by almost two-thirds last year, resulting in significantly reduced payouts for its partners.

time-read
1 min  |
January 04, 2025
Call to stick to tougher green targets amid record EV sales
The Guardian

Call to stick to tougher green targets amid record EV sales

Carmakers sold a record number of electric cars in the UK last year, prompting environmental groups to urge the government to stick to tougher green targets even as the industry argues they are unsustainable.

time-read
2 Minuten  |
January 04, 2025
Handbags and watches help take Thailand PM's declared worth to £322m
The Guardian

Handbags and watches help take Thailand PM's declared worth to £322m

Thailand's prime minister, Paetongtarn Shinawatra, has declared £322m in assets, including a collection of 217 designer handbags and 75 luxury watches in submissions on her wealth to a government body.

time-read
1 min  |
January 04, 2025