Considering how badly South Africa’s parastatals are run, creating more of them is not a good idea.
The word nationalisation is getting thrown around with increasingly reckless abandon in South Africa these days. Its basic definition is to transfer a major branch of industry or commerce from the private sector to state ownership or control.
Some want to nationalise banks, mines, land; others want the state to start up its own versions of certain entities, forgetting perhaps there are already state-owned entities in these areas like the DBSA and Alexkor.
It may be useful to step back a moment and dwell on why governments get involved in industry. The main reason, and the only real valid one, in my opinion, is that the state gets involved in sectors where the private sector does not want to get involved. This tends to be in sectors where the private sector – accountable to shareholders looking for profits – does not think there is money to be made so it would rather not invest.
Yet, states believe these industries or businesses are vital for society to function. The state is not accountable to shareholders, only to voters expecting the state to act in their best interests, even if it means spending money on loss-making enterprises. This does not mean, of course, that the state shouldn’t be operating those businesses responsibly and in the best possible manner.
One example would be public transport, and in particular public trains. Railways are notoriously expensive and difficult to operate. They require huge capital investments and in developing countries like South Africa, where the ticket prices cannot be too high as most won’t be able to afford the fare, this is not a good business case. So the private sector won’t be seen building railway networks worth billions across the country.
Esta historia es de la edición 11 May 2017 de Finweek English.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor ? Conectar
Esta historia es de la edición 11 May 2017 de Finweek English.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor? Conectar
THE HEALTH OF SA'S MEDICAL SCHEMES
As the Covid-19 pandemic abates, finweek takes a look at the financial performance of some of the largest players.
The effect of Gilbertson's departure
With Ntsimbintle Holdings now the major shareholder of Jupiter Mines, it could change SA’s manganese industry.
Making money from music
Why investors are increasingly drawn to the music industry.
Conviction is key
Sandy Rheeder plays a critical role in Mukuru’s mission to open up financial services to the emerging consumer market in Africa through tailor-made technology solutions and platforms.
The post-pandemic toolkit
How CFOs can use technology to support growth.
Big city living exodus
Mini cities like Waterfall City and Steyn City are redefining city-style apartment living.
Big compact, big value
Handsome, with a hefty level of standard specification, the roomy Haval Jolion compact crossover is a great value proposition.
On barriers to entry
There are various ways in which a company or sector can achieve competitive dominance. They usually make for good investments.
Fear and greed in one index
To buck the trend, when markets are hot or cold, is a tough thing to do. However, it can deliver solid returns.
Africa's largest data centre facility coming soon
Vantage Data Centers plans to invest over R15bn for its first African data centre facility in Attacq’s Waterfall City.