Reservation Was Never An Anti-Poverty Measure
Careers 360|March 2019

The government has announced 10 percent reservation for EWS in higher education. What are the pros and cons? Will it stand judicial scrutiny?

P.S.Krishnan
Reservation Was Never An Anti-Poverty Measure

Every problem should have a solution appropriate to the problem, just as every disease must have a medication appropriate to the disease. If somebody has TB, you give drugs for that. If someone has vitamin shortage, you don’t give him medicine for TB. In the same way, reservation cannot solve poverty. Poverty is a different problem of a different dimension. It requires different measures, macro as well as micro- economic.

Finding the right solution

Governments have struggled with this problem, and rightly so. They have to find the right solutions for both unemployment and poverty. Both of these are related. So, for both of these, a different set of policy measures are required. It has to be borne in mind that the problem for which reservation was created was ‘denial of the access of education and avenues for upward and outward mobility, not merely for individuals but collectivises, classes consisting of castes’.

Reservation for economically weaker sections

Our constitution provides for Equality of Opportunity and bars discrimination against any citizens on grounds of caste, religion, place of birth etc. This inter alia means that out of 100 posts, every citizen should have access to every one of 100 posts. The Constitution provides that in order to make Equality of Opportunity real, some of these posts can be made available to those classes who have been, over the centuries, collectively deprived, namely, Scheduled Castes (SCs), Scheduled Tribes (STs) and Socially and Educationally Backward Classes (SEdBCs). Only to this extent can the availability of every one of the 100 posts to every citizen of India be abridged.

Esta historia es de la edición March 2019 de Careers 360.

Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.

Esta historia es de la edición March 2019 de Careers 360.

Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.

MÁS HISTORIAS DE CAREERS 360Ver todo
The 50 colleges in 5 countries where most Indians go for MBBS abroad
Careers 360

The 50 colleges in 5 countries where most Indians go for MBBS abroad

Data on countries and colleges from the Foreign Medical Graduates Examination (FMGE) 2022 - the latest available - shows that most Indians who completed medical degrees abroad and wrote the FMGE went to five countries.

time-read
2 minutos  |
May 2024
Foreign medical colleges: Look before you leap
Careers 360

Foreign medical colleges: Look before you leap

A close look at foreign medical colleges that thousands of Indians have graduated from shows that many are unaccredited, don’t have hospitals or even their own websites

time-read
7 minutos  |
May 2024
'Either I clear FMGE or leave the country'
Careers 360

'Either I clear FMGE or leave the country'

After spending lakhs on MBBS degrees abroad, thousands spend years trying to clear the FMGE. That is the only option for Indian graduates of foreign medical colleges to build a career in India

time-read
7 minutos  |
May 2024
Why hundreds of nursing graduates leave India each year
Careers 360

Why hundreds of nursing graduates leave India each year

There has been an increase in nursing institutes over the past two decades but policy gaps, lax regulations, poor pay and opportunities are pushing a large number of nursing staff to seek opportunities abroad

time-read
8 minutos  |
May 2024
In Kashmir, why NEET and JEE candidates flock to private reading halls to prepare for exams
Careers 360

In Kashmir, why NEET and JEE candidates flock to private reading halls to prepare for exams

These are accessible round-the-clock, even on public holidays, have private cabins and booths, kitchen, discussion area and some, even places for napping

time-read
4 minutos  |
May 2024
Battling despair and depression in medical school
Careers 360

Battling despair and depression in medical school

Long hours, bullying, lack of support make a difficult programme tougher for medical students. They hope for clear guidelines from the NMC

time-read
5 minutos  |
May 2024
This father-daughter duo uncovered a scam in NEET admissions in West Bengal
Careers 360

This father-daughter duo uncovered a scam in NEET admissions in West Bengal

Several generalcategory students had secured admission in medical colleges with forged ST certificates. Ishita Soren spotted the names, and her father followed up

time-read
4 minutos  |
May 2024
'Forced to take up bonded labour
Careers 360

'Forced to take up bonded labour

There's massive resistance to a state policy in Karnataka that requires even private medical college graduates to do one year's mandatory rural service

time-read
6 minutos  |
May 2024
‘A routine circus': PG medical students lobby, move court to get stipends
Careers 360

‘A routine circus': PG medical students lobby, move court to get stipends

Despite NMC orders, many medical colleges still seriously underpay resident doctors and threaten them into silence. In government colleges, stipends can be delayed for months

time-read
5 minutos  |
May 2024
Why Mizoram wants centre to take over its only medical college
Careers 360

Why Mizoram wants centre to take over its only medical college

Mizoram got its first state medical college in 2018. In 2023, it asked the union government to take over. Mixed up in this are questions of funding, MBBS seat distribution

time-read
6 minutos  |
May 2024