Pep Guardiola got a booking for arguing with Eddie Howe at St James' Park, and it was the Newcastle boss who saw his in-game changes come off rather than the City manager.
Howe revitalised his side at half-time and their strong start to the second half was enough to beat a much-changed Blues side.
Still, while City can't win the four major trophies they wanted this season, their chances of winning three again will be stronger for this stormy night in Newcastle. The Blues have a small squad this year, contrary to popular belief, and need every one of them to be ready when called upon this season.
With a number of key men unavailable or exhausted, Guardiola had promised a team full of academy players for this third round Carabao Cup tie.
But he can't help himself when it comes to this competition and named a stronger side than expected.
He said Jack Grealish and Mateo Kovacic would start on the bench, and there they were in the starting line up.
He went through with his promise to rest key men like Kyle Walker, Ruben Dias and Erling Haaland - but there was still more than enough experience in defence and firepower upfront to take on a confident Newcastle side.
Nobody could have predicted that Sergio Gomez would play on the right wing, continuing his return to his natural position, while, Josko Gvardiol got a first start at his preferred centre-back position.
Kalvin Phillips got a first start of the season all together. Nathan Ake, captain for the night in the absence of all five elected captains, was at left-back, popping up in midfield, left-wing and even as a false nine at one point.
Esta historia es de la edición September 28, 2023 de Manchester Evening News.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor ? Conectar
Esta historia es de la edición September 28, 2023 de Manchester Evening News.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor? Conectar
Suspect 'known to victim' as two dead in stabbing
POLICE DESCRIBE DOUBLE KILLING AS 'ISOLATED' AS THEY REASSURE SHOCKED COMMUNITY
Red dawn as boss Amorim takes training
RUBEN Amorim will take training as United head coach for the first time today after his visa to officially start work in the role was approved.
Lollipop man Barry has job he'll stick at
A LOLLIPOP man has become the fifth member of his family to take on the job.
STAR-STUDDED GALA RAISES RECORD SUM TO AID CHILDREN
MOVIE stars joined TV favourites and football legends in Manchester at the city's biggest fundraising ball for another record-breaking night.
Why Reds should Let Leny sink or swim at Ipswich
'THERE IS NO REASON TO EASE YORO INTO ACTION'
Player audit shows need for squad 'surgery' in January
CITY LOOK A PLAYER SHORT IN DEFENCE, MIDFIELD AND ATTACK
I didn't make it at City but now I'm worth £83m
FORMER RIGHT-BACK REECE WABARA SHOWED FLAIR AT ETIHAD ACADEMY BUT EVEN MORE AS A BUSINESSMAN IN FASHION
Rory's World best wins the race again
RORY McIlroy finished the 2024 season in style by adding his third DP World Tour Championship win after winning the sixth Race to Dubai title of his career.
Carsley signs off in style with rout against Ireland
INTERIM boss Lee Carsley signed off in style as England capitalised on Liam Scales' sending off in a 5-0 thrashing of the Republic of Ireland that sealed promotion back to the Nations League top tier.
Bizet's maiden goal helps Reds end run
CELIN Bizet scored her maiden United goal to help them break their three-match winless run with a 2-0 victory over Leicester in the Women's Super League.