Charlotte Proudman criticised a judgment of Sir Jonathan Cohen - a member of the men-only Garrick Club - over remarks he made in a family case two years ago. She knew he was a member of the Garrick when she published a series of tweets expressing criticism, but in a defence she argued she had been making a broader point about "unconscious male bias".
When Proudman discovered this year that Philip Havers, the judge appointed to handle her disciplinary proceedings, was also a member of the Garrick, she made a formal request that he recuse himself on the grounds that a "fairminded and informed observer, having considered these facts, would conclude that there was a real possibility of bias". After considering her request, Havers withdrew himself from the case this month.
There is no suggestion that Cohen and Havers discussed this case or any work matters or ever met at the central London club. But it highlights some of the issues around public perception raised by the membership of significant numbers of Britain's most senior judges of a club that has resisted calls to allow female members since the 1960s.
Esta historia es de la edición March 28, 2024 de The Guardian.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor ? Conectar
Esta historia es de la edición March 28, 2024 de The Guardian.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor? Conectar
FTX files $1.8bn lawsuit against Binance and its former CEO
The collapsed cryptocurrency company FTX is suing Binance and its former CEO Changpeng Zhao, alleging that $1.8bn was \"fraudulently transferred\" by FTX management to Binance and its executives.
Ref's video nasty Coote suspended for foul-mouthed Klopp tirade
The Premier League referee David Coote has been suspended after video footage emerged of him calling Jürgen Klopp a \"German cunt\" and Liverpool \"shit\".
Van Nistelrooy leaves United as Amorim checks in
Ruud van Nistelrooy has left his role as assistant coach after the arrival of Ruben Amorim at Manchester United.
Merino backs Arsenal to stay in title race after 'difficult few weeks'
Mikel Merino insists Arsenal will thrive on the pressure of their bid to win the Premier League and has cited the late push in Sunday's 1-1 draw at Chelsea as evidence of their character.
Robertson not worried after being 'written off' by some
Andy Robertson has said he had a point to prove in Liverpool's win over Aston Villa having been \"written off\" for the first time in his storied Anfield career.
Unfamiliar City woes make this Guardiola's trickiest challenge
The champions struggling in the autumn is nothing new but the root of this season's problems appear different
Coote's mindless rant undermines trust in referees - he can have no complaints over the consequences
There is lots I do not want to know about the video featuring the Premier League referee David Coote.
'Proud father' Gil Gomes reveals a unique family tale
Angel Gomes's dad recalls his own remarkable football journey which took him from Angola to Salford via Hendon
Foden and Palmer among eight England dropouts
Lee Carsley has been rocked by an extraordinary eight withdrawals from his England squad to face Greece and Republic of Ireland in the Nations League, Phil Foden an unexpected name on the absentees list where he joins his Manchester City teammate Jack Grealish.
Ruthless Ruud catches Alcaraz cold in Turin
Carlos Alcaraz made a stuttering start to the ATP Finals in Turin as he suffered a shock first career defeat to the world No 7 Casper Ruud.