When it comes to electoral reform, Labour is politely but completely divided. The members are hugely keen, with 140 local parties submitting the motion that was passed in 2022. The leadership could barely be less interested.
And even though FPTP has just delivered Keir Starmer a big Commons majority, some in the party wonder whether the relatively shaky foundations of this mighty victory necessitate a rethink on electoral reform, if not immediately then before too long.
Sandy Martin, a former MP who now chairs the Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform, said thinking about a move to PR "should be a priority" for the party, despite the way it benefited so handsomely from the current system.
"It would only take Reform and the Conservatives to unite and they might have a majority on the same scale we had this year," he said. "But under PR, Labour would most likely be able to form a government quite comfortably with the Liberal Democrats or the Greens, and this would be preferable to a ConservativeReform government."
As well as self-interest, Martin said, FPTP felt increasingly inappropriate when only 58% of votes went to the two main parties: "In England we now have five parties, and in Scotland and Wales you have six. You can't run a first past the post system - where one party is basically trying to beat the other party - when you've got five or six parties to play with."
Esta historia es de la edición July 17, 2024 de The Guardian.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor ? Conectar
Esta historia es de la edición July 17, 2024 de The Guardian.
Comience su prueba gratuita de Magzter GOLD de 7 días para acceder a miles de historias premium seleccionadas y a más de 9,000 revistas y periódicos.
Ya eres suscriptor? Conectar
Scientists develop 'vaccine' to protect bees from pesticides
Scientists have developed a \"vaccine\" for bees against pesticides - and it appears to work, according to an initial study.
Jewish Chronicle IDF inquiry into claims of stories planted for disinformation campaign
The Israel Defense Forces have launched an investigation into allegations in the Israeli media that the London-based Jewish Chronicle published stories based on \"fabricated intelligence\" relating to Hamas, amid claims they may have been planted as part of a disinformation campaign.
'He is far away in Saudi' Ten Hag brushes off Ronaldo's attack over lack of ambition
Erik ten Hag has hit back at Cristiano Ronaldo by pointing out that the Portuguese admitted Manchester United are not well placed to win the biggest trophies this season despite criticising the manager for stating the same.
So much about the Ballon d'Or suggests that it does not care about women's football
The release of the Ballon d'Or shortlists naturally focused on the absence of Lionel Messi and Cristiano Ronaldo from the men's top 30 for the first time in 21 years, yet the real glaring omissions were to be found among the awards ceremony's token efforts regarding women's football.
Vaughan and Leach shock Surrey to set up title chase
The County Championship title race has been blown wide open after Somerset snatched a dramatic victory over the leaders, Surrey, with a couple of minutes to spare at Taunton, the champions' stout defensive rearguard toppled after they collapsed from 95 for three to 109 all out in a final hour overflowing with tension.
Pettersen backs Hull to light up the course
But captain causes a surprise by omitting Solheim Cup specialist Maguire from today's opening foursomes
Stellantis halts production of Fiat 500 EV for four weeks due to slowdown in European sales
Stellantis said yesterday it would halt production of the electric Fiat 500 model for four weeks owing to a lack of orders in Europe.
Grangemouth oil refinery to shut and become fuel import terminal with 500 jobs at risk
The owners of the Grangemouth oil refinery confirmed yesterday it would shut by the end of June in a blow to Scotland's industrial base and the site's 500 employees.
Refugees Spanish FC leads town's welcome
They filed on to the football pitch as applause rang out, punctuated by shouts of bienvenidos.
Harris heads to swing states buoyed by debate performance
Kamala Harris embarked on a drive to exploit her strong debate performance yesterday, as the Democratic presidential nominee's campaign pledged to intensify efforts to persuade voters in battleground states deemed essential to winning the White House.