Any discussion about the GTI version of the fifth-generation Volkswagen Polo invariably ends with murmurs of respect before everyone agrees they would rather have the rival Ford Fiesta ST. Judged purely on its dynamic merits, the ST is the better car. But the GTI is arguably more rounded and, over time, possibly more satisfying. Still, when it was new, apart from making sure you chose no lower than ST-2 spec, at least the ST got it right from the get-go. If only the same could be said of the GTI.
VW got the engine and gearbox wrong the first time around, and then when it fixed the engine (by replacing it with a larger and more powerful but less complicated one) and at last offered it with a manual gearbox, it wrong-footed buyers by continuing to offer an auto but with the engine's torque much reduced.
It's complicated, but all you need to know is that if you want a Mk5 Polo GTI, buy the facelifted 1.8 TSI with 189bhp, 236lb ft of torque and a manual gearbox, launched in April 2015. Do that and you will be able to leave the Fiesta or Polo debate with your head held high.
Still, we must begin at the beginning, with the first version: the 1.4 Twincharger DSG. No, it didn't have two turbochargers: instead, a turbocharger and a supercharger, the idea being to wring as much power over as broad a rev range as possible from the tiddly engine. The result was 177bhp at 6200rpm but 184lb ft from 2000-4500rpm. These were numbers that Volkswagen's seven-speed dual-clutch transmission (DSG), complete with change paddles, could deal with, so a manual wasn't considered.
Big mistake: both engine and gearbox proved troublesome and Volkswagen's reputation for solid, risk-averse engineering looked threatened. Still, there was good news in the Polo's Golf-inspired hot hatch styling, lowered stance and electronic limited-slip differential to tighten the car's cornering.
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MG 4
An EV changes your driving style - but not to the detriment of pleasure
PEUGEOT E-208
Time with our French hatch is up. Is it good riddance or au revoir?
In the hot seat
Is the best automotive job in the world actually in miniature scale? Hot Wheels' design boss assures STEPHEN DOBIE it is
Correcting the record
Autocar invented the road test back in 1928 - or did we? KEITH JONES trawls the past to find the true starting point
Road test rebooted
As the Autocar road test forges into its second century, its brief is expanding and it's returning to a familiar place. MATT SAUNDERS explains
Cyber attack
MG is back on the international stage and now trying to return to its sports car roots. MATT SAUNDERS sees if the Cyberster EV can match up to a rival from the present and a relation from the past
KIA PICANTO
As rivals fall by the wayside, Kia's popular city car gets a makeover
MASERATI GRANTURISMO
Latest coupé in a long line of Maserati GT cars hits the UK with V6 power
PORSCHE CAYENNE GTS COUPE
New V8 model gets all the goodies
TOYOTA PRIUS
Back by popular demand with a cool new look and greater driver appeal