And the point that told us the most concerned the disconnect between the things England say they want to do in press conferences, and the things they end up doing on the field.
The long and short of it? Talking the talk about modernising a Jurassic-era attacking game powered for far too long by the rugby equivalent of dinosaur dung amounts to precious little if there is no walking of the walk.
Usually, the debate in this area focuses on the inside back combination. Who plays at 10: a big-booted, game-managing Steady Eddie or a twinkle-toed visionary with ideas cascading from his brain like sweat from his forehead? And who plays at 12: a muscle-bound, one-trick shirehorse, or a more rounded individual blessed with something resembling a skill set?
But this is hopelessly reductive, not just on its own terms - George Ford can threaten defences with ball in hand just as seriously as either of the Smiths who want to strip the No.10 shirt from his back; he just does it in a different way - but also in a wider sense. It takes more than a champion midfield to make a champion team.
As one of the great flankers in the annals of the English game, Winterbottom understands better than anyone the importance of a balanced back row unit. He played in a few of those himself. He also played in some that had the kind of balance associated with Ann Widdecombe on Strictly Come Dancing. Which brings us to the current Red. Rose choices.
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Stade are heading in right direction
IS there an early winter equivalent to the idiom about solitary swallows and the impending arrival of summer? Because – whatever it might be, something involving snowflakes, perhaps, or frosts – that’s the situation at Stade Francais right now.
Borthwick needs to sort out defence
WELL surprise, surprise England at last managed to win at home in front of a nearly full Allianz stadium even if it was against a team that they had thrashed just a few months earlier.
Rowland is gearing up for world cup challenge
HELENA Rowland believes England Women have been given advance warning that next year’s Rugby World Cup is to be no formality.
All my energy is going into Beziers
IT’S a dream to be a part-share owner of AS Beziers Hérault, the 11-time French champions, along with Andrew Mehrtens and Bobby Skinstad.
Fylde left to count cost of the cards
LEEDS TYKES were thankful for their resolute defence as they clung on to claim a narrow win against Fylde.
O'Grady glad to learn his trade in tough surroundings
EXETER University flyhalf Lewis O’Grady is enjoying the physicality of National 2 West and insists it is the best preparation for his transition to senior rugby after graduation.
It's Bristol or nothing for me - Cunningham
PROUD Bristolian Hollie Cunningham hopes to inspire the next generation of Bears players and can’t see herself ever playing for anyone else.
Bristol hit heights to take down champions
BRISTOL Bears head coach Dave Ward could not hide his delight following an impressive victory over reigning PWR champions Gloucester Hartpury at Kingsholm.
Good to see the Eagles soaring again
THAT’S a wrap for the autumn Tests and it would be remiss not to scroll through the undercard and round up the best of the action outside of the A list matches. A quick crib sheet for those not paying attention at the back.
Thomas ready for Edinburgh clash
FRESH from his dream Wales debut, Freddie Thomas has set his sights on helping Gloucester conquer Europe.