Townsend's Gregor men appeared to be well on their way to a ninth consecutive Championship victory in this fixture as they racked up three tries in the opening half-hour en route to a 2210 lead.
Even when Italy, who had lost their last 26 home games in the Championship since 2013, reached the interval within six points, the game was still well within the Scots' command.
But the momentum shifted dramatically when what would have been a fourth Scotland try, for scrum-half George Horne, was ruled out for a clumsy obstruction by prop Pierre Schoeman early in the second half.
Within two minutes new Italy wing Louis Lynagh collected a chip over the top to dot down a debut try and suddenly belief flowed through Azzurri ranks.
In contrast, the technical and mental frailties. that have prevented Scotland from managing more than three wins in any Six Nations and becoming genuine contenders resurfaced once again.
They conceded a string of penalties - seven to Italy's one in the second half - and lost the clinical edge in attack that had served them so well in the opening period.
Scotland still have a Triple Crown to play for in Dublin on Saturday, but having not beaten Ireland in nine meetings under Townsend, it would be a brave man who bet on them breaking that streak.
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Gallagher's late brace proves key for Caldy
CALDY built upon recent improved performances against London Scottish and Ealing to record a bonus point win against fourth placed Nottingham in a thrilling battle at Paton Field.
Leicester gunning to take down a legend
MICHAEL Cheika is aiming to take down a French icon as his Tigers attempt their Champions Cup mission impossible in Toulouse today and upset his children in the process.
Charnock the class has to end Havant resistance
A MUCH improved second-half performance saw Westevencombe Park tually overcome a spirited Havant side who looked like providing an upset for much of the game.
Quins turn on style to rip Sharks apart
A STORMING second-half mance saw perforQuins romp to a seven-try victory on the road.
Williams is poised to shift up a gear
TEDDY Williams will be looking to put his international disappointments behind him now his remarkable shift this season has been rewarded with a Wales call-up.
Mitchell back to his best and ready for battle
ALEX Mitchell is now eight games into his injury-delayed season and feeling full of energy for the Six Nations campaign ahead of him.
Borthwick: It's time to put our foot down
STEVE Borthwick insists he has come up with a solution to problem England's in closing out matches be even quicker out of the blocks in the upcoming Six Nations.
Watson: I had to quit, I was in so much pain
AS Anthony Watson trudged off five minutes into the second-half in Leicester's match at Sale in December, he knew deep down that his career was over.
Seabrook hat-trick as Saints edge a thriller
A STIRRING contest ended in Saints scrambling heroically to gain a last 16 home tie and gallant Munster facing a knockout tie on the road.
Barritt backing the new boys
BRAD Barritt won the Champions Cup three times with Saracens and believes the club are on course to be a powerhouse in the competition again.