In its landmark judgment, a bench comprising Justices Abhay S Oka, Ahsanuddin Amanullah and AG Masih emphasised that delays in executing death sentences, particularly those arising from administrative inefficiencies, violate the fundamental rights of convicts under Article 21 of the Constitution.
The ruling came while the court upheld a Bombay high court decision to commute the death sentences of two convicts in the 2007 Pune BPO rape and murder case to 35 years of imprisonment. The convicts, including the driver of the office cab, brutally assaulted and murdered a young woman after abducting her. They were initially sentenced to death by the trial court—a decision that was affirmed by the high court and also by the Supreme Court in 2015. However, their execution was delayed by over three years due to administrative lapses, prompting the high court to reduce their punishment.
The Supreme Court, concurring with this decision, observed that such inordinate delays inflicted unnecessary psychological and physical suffering on the convicts, rendering the death penalty inhumane and unconstitutional for violating Article 21 of the Constitution guaranteeing the right to life and dignity.
Acknowledging a "casual and negligent" approach by executive authorities in handling mercy petitions, the bench mandated the establishment of dedicated cells within the home or prison departments of all state governments and Union territories to ensure swift processing.
The bench reinforced that prolonged delays in processing mercy petitions or issuing execution warrants infringe on a convict's fundamental rights under Article 21, stating that "the sword of Damocles could not be kept hanging over convicts indefinitely because the resulting mental and physical anguish amounted to cruel and degrading treatment.
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Syria Announces End of Operation Against Assad 'Regime Remnants'
Syria's interim government on Monday announced the end of a days-long military operation against insurgents loyal to ousted president Bashar Assad and his family in the worst fighting since the end of the 13-year civil war in December.
Rohit-Gill combo gave India edge
Rohit took the match away from us: Santner
Courts Can't Award Damages While Hearing Bail Pleas: SC
The Supreme Court has ruled that courts cannot order compensation while adjudicating a bail plea because they lack the jurisdiction to do so in bail proceedings.
13 Held for Violence During India's Cricket Win Celebrations in Mhow
Thirteen people have been arrested in connection with clashes in Mhow town of Madhya Pradesh after stone pelting at a rally celebrating the Indian cricket team's victory in the ICC Champions Trophy final, officials said on Monday.
Carney set to replace Trudeau as next PM
Former central banker Mark Carney coasted to a landslide victory to become the new leader of the ruling Liberal Party, paving the way for him to succeed Justin Trudeau as Canada's Prime Minister.
Indian Shares Fall as US Tariff Concerns Keep Investors on Edge
Indian shares ended lower on Monday, with the broader market seeing sharper cuts as concerns over U.S. tariffs and the ongoing market decline kept investors on edge.
Sun Pharma to Buy US Oncology Firm for $355 Million
Sun Pharmaceutical Industries Ltd. has agreed to buy US-based immunotherapy and oncology firm Checkpoint Therapeutics Inc. for an upfront payment of $355 million, as India's largest drug-maker bolsters its specialty therapy portfolio.
Cyber fraud losses have surged 10-fold in a decade, says Finmin
Losses due to cyber frauds have surged nearly 10-fold in a decade, Pankaj Chaudhary, minister of state in the finance ministry, said on Monday.
Ram Mandir Construction Committee's Tenure to End This Year
Amid delays, the Ram Mandir Construction Committee has decided to expedite the construction works in Ram Janmabhoomi and complete them before the completion of its tenure by the end of this year, the committee's chairman Nripendra Misra said on Sunday.
Experts warn of addiction risks in pain medicine usage
As advancements in pain relief and rehabilitation medicine continue, medical experts caution that prolonged use of certain pain medications, including opioids like morphine, may lead to addiction, making it difficult for patients to quit.
