The 27-year-old centre back was part of Lindsey's Crawley Town team that battered MK 8-1 on aggregate in last season's play-off semi-final before going on to win promotion at Wembley against Crewe.
That success has been described as a "massive over-achievement" by Maguire with the Red Devils having been tipped for relegation at the start of the campaign.
Subsequently, the younger brother of Manchester United and England defender Harry opted to move to the Dons over the summer.
Decision
Lindsey made the same decision when he was approached after Mike Williamson moved on to Carlisle with the club having lost six of their opening eight 2024-25 fixtures in all competitions.
Under former Swindon boss Lindsey, MK drew their first game 1-1 at Bromley before registering their first away win since April on Tuesday with a devastating 5-1 hammering of Harrogate.
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the {{IssueName}} edition of {{MagazineName}}.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
MATT'S BOYS SHOW CLASS
WYCOMBE side-stepped a tricky second round fixture by defeating Wealdstone at Grosvenor Vale.
LUKE SEETHES OVER SLOPPY SWANS START
LUKE Williams admitted he gave his players the hairdryer treatment at half-time after seeing them come into the break trailing against bottom of the table Portsmouth.
UPSET FOR HARRIS AS TYLER HITS STUNNER
Neil Harris insisted the fact that Millwall were bitterly disappointed to claim only a point shows the progress his side have made over the past 10 months.
ANTE AT THE DOUBLE FOR ON-SONG CITY
NORWICH head coach Johannes Hoff Thorup paid tribute to the home fans after watching his side come through a tough test against Luton to win comfortably in the end.
WAYNE'S WORLD OF PAIN AS ARGYLE FOLD
WAYNE Rooney talked of \"the toughest week of my managerial career\" after watching his Plymouth side capitulate for the second time in four days.
WAYNE'S WORLD OF PAIN AS ARGYLE FOLD
WAYNE Rooney talked of \"the toughest week of my managerial career\" after watching his Plymouth side capitulate for the second time in four days.
Cleverley buzzed by Hornets' form
TOM Cleverley insists that his side's goalless draw against Queens Park Rangers at Vicarage Road is another building block rather than a disappointing result against a relegation-threatened team.
FRANK SEES POSITIVES AFTER LATE EQUALISER
COVENTRY head coach Frank Lampard admitted he has plenty to work on after his first match in charge ended with a draw against fellow strugglers Cardiff.
IT'S MORE AGONY FOR TAME TIGERS
HULL City's interim boss Andy Dawson says everyone at the club is \"feeling the pain\" after their dismal run of defeats stretched to five games with a loss at Middlesbrough.
CARLOS: I MAKE THE DECISIONS ON SUBS
Carlos Corberan defended his substitutions after West Brom drew with Preston.
