The brutish empire
BBC History Magazine|April 2022
ALEX VON TUNZELMANN considers a global investigation into the intrinsic connection between racialised violence and the history of the world's largest-ever empire
ALEX VON TUNZELMANN
The brutish empire

The British empire CAROLINE ELKINS nominally ceased to exist in 1947, when India and Pakistan became independent (though substantial imperial power endured well into the Commonwealth period). Even 75 years later, though, questions and controversies about it are still rarely out of the news. Harvard professor Caroline Elkins is the latest historian to try to tell one aspect of its immense story. In the introduction, she declares: “My hope is that it [this book] will inform today's imperial history wars and struggles for racial equality, pushing debates over whether or not the British empire was a good or a bad thing, or better or worse than other imperial ventures, toward asking how and why the empire's past continues to shape the present."

Legacy of Violence: A History of the British Empire by Caroline Elkins Bodley Head, 896 pages, £30

It is an admirable aim to sidestep the culture wars and engage directly with the facts but Legacy of Violence will probably upset defenders of the British empire before they have even opened it. As its title suggests, the book views the whole history of empire through the lens of violence - in particular, racialised violence.

No doubt the defenders would rather view the empire through the rosier spectacles of what they consider to be its achievements: the railways, cricket, the rule of law, and so forth. By the end of this book, Elkins has smashed those spectacles to bits and ground their fragments into the mud. “Violence was not just the British empire's midwife,” she asserts, "it was endemic to the structures and systems of British rule. It was not just an occasional means to liberal imperialism's end; it was a means and an end for as long as the British empire remained alive."

この記事は BBC History Magazine の April 2022 版に掲載されています。

7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トライアルを開始して、何千もの厳選されたプレミアム ストーリー、9,000 以上の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしてください。

この記事は BBC History Magazine の April 2022 版に掲載されています。

7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トライアルを開始して、何千もの厳選されたプレミアム ストーリー、9,000 以上の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしてください。

BBC HISTORY MAGAZINEのその他の記事すべて表示
The King They Couldn't Kill -Want to know why Henry VII is remembered as an intensely suspicious king, wracked by paranoia? The answer, writes Nathen Amin, lies in his death-defying rise to power
BBC History UK

The King They Couldn't Kill -Want to know why Henry VII is remembered as an intensely suspicious king, wracked by paranoia? The answer, writes Nathen Amin, lies in his death-defying rise to power

Henry’s wary nature is typically attributed to his shaky claim to the throne. The first Tudor monarch was unable to escape the taunt that he was a usurper with no right to call himself king. In fact, his renowned paranoia was the inevitable consequence of a traumatic youth – a trait ingrained long before he harboured ambitions to wear a crown. If we delve deeper into Henry’s background, we can draw a fuller picture of one of our most circumspect of monarchs – one that might elicit sympathy for a long misunderstood king.

time-read
10+ 分  |
September 2024
The Spy Who Hoodwinked Hitler - Dummy tanks at El Alamein. Bogus generals in Algiers. Sham armies on D-Day. All were ruses masterminded by Dudley Clarke. Robert Hutton tells the story of the British soldier who made an art form of duping the Nazis
BBC History UK

The Spy Who Hoodwinked Hitler - Dummy tanks at El Alamein. Bogus generals in Algiers. Sham armies on D-Day. All were ruses masterminded by Dudley Clarke. Robert Hutton tells the story of the British soldier who made an art form of duping the Nazis

Examining the reconnaissance photos, Behrendt was convinced that the Allies weren’t in any hurry. They were constructing some kind of pipeline towards the southern end of their line, probably to carry water, which was barely halfway completed. There were supply dumps appearing in the south as well – always a telltale clue about where an attack would come. True, a large number of trucks were parked at the northern end of the line, about 25 miles back from the front, but they hadn’t moved for weeks.

time-read
10+ 分  |
September 2024
"People have achieved all kinds of crazy things at the age of 18″
BBC History UK

"People have achieved all kinds of crazy things at the age of 18″

ALICE LOXTON talks to Danny Bird about her book on 18 individuals who left an indelible mark on British history before they were out of their teens

time-read
10+ 分  |
September 2024
Parthian chicken
BBC History UK

Parthian chicken

ELEANOR BARNETT recreates an ancient Roman dish that borrowed flavours from a rival neighbouring empire in the Middle East

time-read
2 分  |
September 2024
"We need a meaningful story for the new generation - our composite union"
BBC History UK

"We need a meaningful story for the new generation - our composite union"

WHAT A SUMMER IT’S BEEN SO FAR, WITH AN astonishing election result.

time-read
3 分  |
September 2024
A Pole apart
BBC History UK

A Pole apart

ROGER MOORHOUSE is absorbed by a little-known but politically significant Polish princess whose life encompassed the major events of the later 18th and 19th centuries

time-read
4 分  |
September 2024
Medieval England's p olitical miracle
BBC History UK

Medieval England's p olitical miracle

From Magna Carta to parliament, taxation to the law courts, the 13th and 14th centuries laid the foundations for the modern British state

time-read
9 分  |
September 2024
EASTERN PROMISES
BBC History UK

EASTERN PROMISES

Lured by rich trading prospects, from the 17th to the 19th centuries Britain attempted to cultivate relations with China sometimes successfully, but often disastrously. Kerry Brown explores the troubled but ultimately vital links between two ambitious realms

time-read
10 分  |
September 2024
THE GENIUS IN THE SHADOWS
BBC History UK

THE GENIUS IN THE SHADOWS

Æthelstan is one of the greatest of all Anglo-Saxon monarchs. So why, asks Michael Wood, does the first king of the English remain so fiendishly elusive?

time-read
10 分  |
September 2024
The long road back The election was tough for the Conservatives - but the past holds clues on how parties can return from the brink
BBC History UK

The long road back The election was tough for the Conservatives - but the past holds clues on how parties can return from the brink

It’s election night 1997, and Jeremy Paxman is grilling Tory grandee Cecil Parkinson.

time-read
6 分  |
September 2024