Basic Structure Doctrine in Canada?
India Legal|November 01, 2021
The recent decision of the Supreme Court of Canada makes one wonder whether there is any other example of more complex and contradictory discourse than the question concerning the nature and limits of constitutional constituent power!
Upendra Baci
Basic Structure Doctrine in Canada?

CONTRARY to a public adage, good news does not always travel fast! The doctrine of basic structure and essential features has travelled well, ever since it was judicially invented and articulated, in Kesavananda Bharati (1973), and its magnificent decisional progeny, has extended to South Asia, and the New Commonwealth of Nations.

The recent decision of the Supreme Court of Canada in City of Toronto vs Attorney General, Ontario (appeal heard March 16, 2021, judgment made on October 1, 2021) marks a somewhat fractured beginning. In a deeply divided reasoning and result, Justices Abella, Karakatsanis, Martin, and Kasirer JJ. disagreed with the joint opinion of Chief Justice Wagner and Brown J. (with Moldaver, Côté and Rowe JJ. concurring).

The judicial disagreement will not surprise Indian readers accustomed to a riot of meanings of prolix majority, partial concurring opinions and some dissentient judicial discourse. But the expedition with which the case was heard and decided surely will; and so, will the brevity of decisional text on so important a matter. It is a 186-paragraph decision, with the majority writing 85 and the dissent writing the rest. It shows that it is both possible and desirable to write in a succinct manner even on so complicated a matter. One wonders whether there is any other example of more complex and contradictory discourse than the question concerning the nature and limits of constitutional constituent power!

Although, it was a wafer-thin majority (a 5-4 decision), it would be wrong to characterize it as a majority/minority discourse all the way.

この記事は India Legal の November 01, 2021 版に掲載されています。

7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トライアルを開始して、何千もの厳選されたプレミアム ストーリー、9,000 以上の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしてください。

この記事は India Legal の November 01, 2021 版に掲載されています。

7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トライアルを開始して、何千もの厳選されたプレミアム ストーリー、9,000 以上の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしてください。

INDIA LEGALのその他の記事すべて表示
PIL, Difficult To Swallow?
India Legal

PIL, Difficult To Swallow?

In a recent ruling, the Bombay High Court lamented the increasing number of frivolous public interest litigations being filed in courts and echoed the sentiments of the Supreme Court that such litigations are the bane of the judicial system. Is there any way to restrict their misuse?

time-read
6 分  |
February 13, 2023
Till Infertility Do Us Part...
India Legal

Till Infertility Do Us Part...

The Calcutta High Court slammed a husband for initiating divorce proceedings due to his wife's infertility and asked him to be a pillar of support for her. Courts have often taken an empathetic view in such matters

time-read
4 分  |
February 13, 2023
IS THAT LEGAL?
India Legal

IS THAT LEGAL?

Ignorance of law is no excuse. Here are answers to frequently asked queries regarding matters that affect us on a day-to-day basis

time-read
3 分  |
February 13, 2023
The Big Lie
India Legal

The Big Lie

In America, The Big Lie is an idiom used by Donald Trump's opponents and the media to describe his constant gripe about election fraud. Now, it seems more suited to another Republican, Congressman George Santos (right), who has been facing growing calls to resign after he admitted fabricating parts of his resume and biography since his election in New York last year.

time-read
1 min  |
February 13, 2023
Flying into the Sunset
India Legal

Flying into the Sunset

Over 50 years since the first and original jumbo jet, the Boeing 747, took to the skies and revolutionized air travel, the last of the legendary aircraft (right) was delivered to a freight charter company, bringing down the curtain on one of aviation's most successful products.

time-read
1 min  |
February 13, 2023
Star Crossed
India Legal

Star Crossed

Actor and producer Alec Baldwin is a Hollywood legend, having starred in a range of movies, award winning TV sitcoms, and theatre. He was most recently seen in Mission Impossible Fallout, which is an apt description of his current situation.

time-read
1 min  |
February 13, 2023
Walkouts in the UK
India Legal

Walkouts in the UK

An estimated half a million workers have gone on strike, shutting down thousands of schools, public transport and border disruption. It is the biggest day of industrial action for more than a decade.

time-read
1 min  |
February 13, 2023
Myanmar's Misery
India Legal

Myanmar's Misery

Two years after the military coup ousted the elected government led by Aung San Suu Kyi, the brutal crackdown by the junta on so-called \"insurgents\" and civilian protesters has reached a new level with the use of air strikes, a new and deadly tactic in the ongoing civil war.

time-read
1 min  |
February 13, 2023
AMERICA'S ANGST
India Legal

AMERICA'S ANGST

From messy, divisive politics to a series of mass shootings, and now black officers brutally beating another black man to death as seen in bodycam videos, America's domestic convulsions are cause for serious introspection

time-read
4 分  |
February 13, 2023
JUSTICE LEAGUE
India Legal

JUSTICE LEAGUE

There are few judicial appointment procedures in the world that are completely bereft of the overarching presence of either the executive or the legislature, or both. In the end, the judge is left with all the powers vested in him/her by the constitution to uphold the rule of law, within an atmosphere of external influences

time-read
9 分  |
February 13, 2023