Mckenzie: ‘We Feel Really Good About Conley'

Just what happened in that Cleveland hotel room in the early morning hours of April 9 remains uncertain to everyone outside of Gareon Conley and his 23-year-old accuser.

About the only thing that is certain is that the two were together that night at some point and that their stories take a wildly different course after that.

Conley, 21, is accused of raping the woman he had met earlier in the evening, less than three weeks before he was to be a sure first-round pick in the draft. According to a police report, Conley initially met the woman at around 3 a.m., invited her back to his hotel then asked her if she was interested in watching another couple have sex.

At some point, the woman walked into a bathroom in the hotel room and was followed by Conley who then allegedly assaulted her.

But two witnesses who were in the room at the time and were interviewed by police told authorities that there was no rape, while Conley has said that the sex was consensual. He also took a polygraph test and had offered to give DNA samples.