Lessons In The Defence Indigenisation Maze
Geopolitics|May 2018

The recent statement by a minister of the Central Government that ‘Make in India’ of defence projects was literally a non-starter, comes as no surprise to people engaged in such business. ‘Self-Reliance’ and ‘Indigenisation’ are now better associated with seminars and conferences across the country than with actual military hardware. For some of us associated with this sector for the last six decades, this has remained a well known harsh reality, highlights G RAJ NARAYAN, MD, Radel Group

- G Raj Narayan
Lessons In The Defence Indigenisation Maze

Lesson 1 - While the present PM’s slogan of ‘Make in India’ is a refreshing slogan echoed effortlessly by the rest of the establishment, nobody seems to have the faintest idea of what this implies. Some believe that this is an open invitation to foreign companies to set shop in India and churn out products that can be labelled ‘Made in India’, as the Su-30s have been for the last three decades. Some others believe that this will necessitate technology transfer to Indian companies so that they can build on them in the future. There are also many like this author, who believe that no OEM would ever transfer technology of any sort other than partial manufacturing drawings and process sheets. History over the last 50 years has proven the last belief to be correct. Whether it was the Gnat or Jaguar or MiG-21 or Su-30, we have had to be at the mercy of the foreign OEMs right through the lifecycles for spares and maintenance support at huge costs. This is proof that we Indians never learn lessons in life.

Lesson 2 – Defence Public Sector Undertakings (DPSUs) set up over the last six decades certainly served the purpose of establishing a manufacturing base that involved huge capital investments that was beyond the means of the private sector of those days. But, over the years, these have relegated to being sleeping giants delivering only a fraction of what they are capable of. Worse, they are keeping their exposure to military technologies over decades shrouded like Egyptian mummies. This has prevented the assimilation of domain technologies, however outdated they may be, by the private sector. The result: ‘Dog in the Manger’.

この蚘事は Geopolitics の May 2018 版に掲茉されおいたす。

7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トラむアルを開始しお、䜕千もの厳遞されたプレミアム ストヌリヌ、9,000 以䞊の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしおください。

この蚘事は Geopolitics の May 2018 版に掲茉されおいたす。

7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トラむアルを開始しお、䜕千もの厳遞されたプレミアム ストヌリヌ、9,000 以䞊の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしおください。

GEOPOLITICSのその他の蚘事すべお衚瀺
NEW MANTRA FOR DISPUTE RESOLUTION
Geopolitics

NEW MANTRA FOR DISPUTE RESOLUTION

AMIT COWSHISH explains why the Ministry of Defence (MOD), which is one of the biggest spenders, needs to watch out for the latest mediation rules.

time-read
10+ 分  |
August 2024
NEW WAVE TERRORISM IN JAMMU & KASHMIR
Geopolitics

NEW WAVE TERRORISM IN JAMMU & KASHMIR

KARAN KHARB argues that Pakistan's continued use of proxy war tactics against India, particularly in Jammu and Kashmir, poses a severe threat to national security. He advocates for a shift from a reactive to a proactive approach in counter-terrorism efforts, emphasizing the need for a comprehensive review of military strategies and a coordinated national policy to address both external and internal security challenges effectively.

time-read
9 分  |
August 2024
INDIAN NAVY'S PROJECT-751 - GERMAN TKMS LEADS SPANISH NAVANTIA AFTER FIELD TRIALS FOR AIP-SUBMARINE DEAL
Geopolitics

INDIAN NAVY'S PROJECT-751 - GERMAN TKMS LEADS SPANISH NAVANTIA AFTER FIELD TRIALS FOR AIP-SUBMARINE DEAL

German submarine-builder ThyssenKrupp (TKMS) and India's Mazagaon Dockyard Limited (MDL) have emerged as leaders in the Indian Navy's Project-751, which aims to build six submarines with Fuel Cell Air-Independent Propulsion (AIP) and Lithium-ion batteries. Following successful field trials, TKMS and MDL have gained an edge over competitors by demonstrating their proven AIP technology and advanced submarine design tailored to the Indian Navy's needs.

time-read
3 分  |
August 2024
VIKSIT BHARAT FROM A DREAM TO REALITY
Geopolitics

VIKSIT BHARAT FROM A DREAM TO REALITY

The article explores India's ascent as a global influencer, emphasising its strategic advancements in foreign policy, defence, and economic growth. It also highlights India's challenges in achieving sustainable development and strengthening internal security. Adopting a forward-looking approach, the article envisions India's rise as a major economic power and a key player in global stability, as outlined by LT. GEN. A.B. SHIVANE (RETD.).

time-read
5 分  |
August 2024
WILL MODI APPLY THE LESSON LEARNT FROM KOREA IN UKRAINE?
Geopolitics

WILL MODI APPLY THE LESSON LEARNT FROM KOREA IN UKRAINE?

Speculation around Prime Minister Narendra Modi's possible visit to Ukraine raises questions about India's role in mediating peace between Russia and Ukraine. Drawing from its experience during the Korean War, India may seek to leverage its strategic neutrality to foster dialogue in a conflict where China and Turkey have also shown interest, opines PRAKASH NANDA.

time-read
6 分  |
August 2024
UGVS: THE NEXT DIMENSION OF WARFARE
Geopolitics

UGVS: THE NEXT DIMENSION OF WARFARE

With the rest of the world developing unmanned ground vehicles at a breakneck speed, it is time for India to join the bandwagon at the earliest.

time-read
9 分  |
August 2024
SUPERSONIC DESTROYER
Geopolitics

SUPERSONIC DESTROYER

The BrahMos programme has filled a critical gap in the Indian armed forces' missile inventory and continues to attract strong export interest, writes ATUL CHANDRA.

time-read
8 分  |
August 2024
POLICE MODERNISATION: AN URGENT NEED OF THE HOUR
Geopolitics

POLICE MODERNISATION: AN URGENT NEED OF THE HOUR

India is facing many internal security threats, and it is time to reshape the strategic dynamics by modernising the police forces.

time-read
9 分  |
August 2024
FUTURE FIGHTER
Geopolitics

FUTURE FIGHTER

FIA 24 provided important insights into the Global Combat Air Programme, which will redefine the future of air combat, reports MIKE RAJKUMAR.

time-read
7 分  |
August 2024
FILLING THE GAP
Geopolitics

FILLING THE GAP

A new Medium Transport Aircraft is essential for the IAF, but it will have to compete with other pressing programmes fighting for limited budgetary resources, analyses ATUL CHANDRA.

time-read
8 分  |
August 2024