Couple SWAP

While T.J. Holmes and Amy Robach are going strong, their exes have struck up a romance of their own

Amy Robach and T.J. Holmes were all smiles on the red carpet at iHeart Radio’s Jingle Ball NYC on Dec. 8 as they also celebrated the launch of their podcast, Amy & T.J., earlier that week. But behind the scenes, their exes, Andrew Shue and Marilee Fiebig, had already stolen the show. On Dec. 5, the same day as their debut episode, news broke that Shue and Fiebig were dating, and the couple were spotted together for the first time as they loaded up the actor’s Jeep Wrangler before heading off for the weekend.

The pair have been seeing each other “for about six months,” an insider tells Us, explaining that Shue and Fiebig, an immigration lawyer, bonded over the trauma of their heartbreaking splits after their former spouses’ affair was exposed in 2022.

“They were spending time together and realized their morals and values were really aligned. They never expected their friendship to turn into romance.”