In the early years of our country, public men who felt maligned could end up killing over it. The duel that resulted in Alexander Hamilton’s death was prompted by a letter, in the Albany Register, by someone claiming that Hamilton had called Aaron Burr “a dangerous man, and one who ought not to be trusted with the reins of the government,” and had expressed a “still more despicable opinion” (without further specifics). Instead of redressing an insult to honor through violence, Burr could have tried to sue under the law of defamation— the legal system’s attempt to channel retaliation into a court process. He was certainly familiar with it; as a lawyer, he had used it to go after critics. One probable reason he didn’t was that it was undignified for a gentleman to take a social equal to court.
In the decades that followed, putative defamers became more likely to pay for their words with money than with their lives. Only in the past sixty years, though, did the legal balance shift strongly in their favor: wrecking reputations has, under civil law, become much less risky. The media, for the most part, have been free to publish about public figures without great fear of legal repercussions. That protection derives from New York Times v. Sullivan, a 1964 Supreme Court decision that made it harder to win defamation suits against the media. The Court had argued that the press in a democracy must be able to criticize government officials, and the landmark decision is widely seen as indispensable to a free press.
この記事は The New Yorker の May 22, 2023 版に掲載されています。
7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トライアルを開始して、何千もの厳選されたプレミアム ストーリー、9,000 以上の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしてください。
すでに購読者です ? サインイン
この記事は The New Yorker の May 22, 2023 版に掲載されています。
7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トライアルを開始して、何千もの厳選されたプレミアム ストーリー、9,000 以上の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしてください。
すでに購読者です? サインイン
TAKE TWO
\"The Hills of California\" and \"Yellow Face\" come to Broadway.
DOWNWARD SPIRALS
Missy Mazzoli's \"The Listeners\" and Jeanine Tesori's \"Grounded.\"
IT TAKES A VILLAGE
The exuberant, complicating drawings of the Shakers.
THE LONG CON
Rachel Kushner's anti-spy, anti-realism novel.
IF MEMORY SERVES
John Lewis knew how to put a legacy of heroism.
SILICON VALLEY'S INFLUENCE GAME
From crypto to A.I., tech titans are pouring money into super PACS to savage their political opponents.
WHEN THE ICE MELTS
What the fate of the Arctic means for the rest of the Earth.
SLEEP ESSENTIAL FOR HEALTH
To achieve good health, you must maintain a regular sleep schedule, and be able to get back to sleep once you are awake.
THE K-POP KING
Chairman Bang is bringing his formula for creating idols to the U.S.
THE SIGHTED WORLD
Growing up with the writer Ved Mehta.