HUMZA Yousaf's greatest achievement in the last 12 months has been holding on to his job.
He has faced the most turbulent start of any first minister in the history of devolution and survived.
He is not a perfect politician but he is a resilient one.
All leaders have to balance weathering the storms of everyday troubles with delivering the sunny uplands promised to voters.
Most of his time in office has been spent under black clouds he could not dodge.
Within weeks of him becoming First Minister, predecessor Nicola Sturgeon and her husband Peter Murrell were arrested amid an SNP fraud probe.
Even though they were released without charge, the ongoing Operation Branchform still haunts Yousaf's leadership.
The scandal of Sturgeon and her team deleting their Covid WhatsApps was another mess that landed on his lap.
And the taxpayer-funded farce of his Health Secretary Michael Matheson's data roaming bill sapped even more of his energy.
Yousaf's early support for Matheson contributed to the growing sense of crisis but all three debacles were not of Yousaf's making.
He also inherited a shambles from Sturgeon on indyref2 after her preferred approach of going to the UK Supreme Court failed.
The legitimate criticism of Yousaf is the slow progress - in some areas he has even gone backwards in meeting his key goals.
ãã®èšäºã¯ Daily Record ã® March 27, 2024 çã«æ²èŒãããŠããŸãã
7 æ¥éã® Magzter GOLD ç¡æãã©ã€ã¢ã«ãéå§ããŠãäœåãã®å³éžããããã¬ãã¢ã ã¹ããŒãªãŒã9,000 以äžã®éèªãæ°èã«ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹ããŠãã ããã
ãã§ã«è³Œèªè ã§ã ?  ãµã€ã³ã€ã³
ãã®èšäºã¯ Daily Record ã® March 27, 2024 çã«æ²èŒãããŠããŸãã
7 æ¥éã® Magzter GOLD ç¡æãã©ã€ã¢ã«ãéå§ããŠãäœåãã®å³éžããããã¬ãã¢ã ã¹ããŒãªãŒã9,000 以äžã®éèªãæ°èã«ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹ããŠãã ããã
ãã§ã«è³Œèªè ã§ã? ãµã€ã³ã€ã³
KEEP CALM & VALAKARI ON
New boss still watching from stand but Kirk says it Saint an obstacle
NO MAD THING
Slot says he's not worried about TAA to Real talk
Kids need a healthy diet to concentrate
Five-a-day fruit and veg scheme a major boost
NEIGH LUCK
Kelpies creator Andy tells how work dried up after he finished landmark.
Sails force greets the royals on Aussie trip
THE famous sails of Sydney Opera House give the King and Queen a special welcome as they touch down on their tour of Australia.
CHIP SHOP ASSAULTS RAP STAR QUITS CLUB
A SCOTTISH Premiership club has announced the departure of a player after he was charged with assault.
NOW END THE WAR
Peace plea after death of Hamas Oct 7 chief
Tributes to 'angel' Alana killed in A71 horror smash
A WOMAN who was killed in a horror crash in Ayrshire has been named locally as barmaid Alana Muir.
Bus driver death: Teen pleads guilty
Drunk yob headbutted and rained punches on Keith
REEVES EYES INHERITANCE IN TAX RAIDS
Chancellor also mulls welfare cuts to find £40bn