While Chief Justice of India Dhananjaya Y Chandrachud, in a majority opinion that he authored for himself and six other judges, criticised earlier judgments for their perceived economic biases and ideologies, justices BV Nagarathna and Sudhanshu Dhulia vehemently defended the historical context of those rulings, branding the majority's assessment as "unwarranted" and "harsh." The majority judgment asserted that prior interpretations by justices Krishna Iyer in State of Karnataka Vs Ranganatha Reddy (1977) and O Chinnappa Reddy in the Sanjeev Coke case (1982) -which included privately owned property within the ambit of "material resources of the community"--were flawed.
In the Ranganatha Reddy case, a seven-judge bench considered the application of Article 39(b) in the context of nationalisation of contract carriages. The majority view of four judges did not favour private property to fall under Article 39(b). However, the minority view pronounced by justice Iyer held to the contrary. Justice Iyer said: "Material resources of the community in the context of reordering the national economy embraces all the national wealth, not merely natural resources, all the private and public sources of meeting material needs, not merely public possessions... To exclude ownership of private resources from the coils of Article 39(b) is to cipherise its very purpose of redistribution the socialist way." This minority view later became the basis of a five-judge bench decision in the Sanjeev Coke case where the issue of Article 39(b) arose in the context of nationalisation of coke oven plants. Justice Reddy held private property to be part of material resources of community.
ãã®èšäºã¯ Hindustan Times ã® November 06, 2024 çã«æ²èŒãããŠããŸãã
7 æ¥éã® Magzter GOLD ç¡æãã©ã€ã¢ã«ãéå§ããŠãäœåãã®å³éžããããã¬ãã¢ã ã¹ããŒãªãŒã9,000 以äžã®éèªãæ°èã«ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹ããŠãã ããã
ãã§ã«è³Œèªè ã§ã ?  ãµã€ã³ã€ã³
ãã®èšäºã¯ Hindustan Times ã® November 06, 2024 çã«æ²èŒãããŠããŸãã
7 æ¥éã® Magzter GOLD ç¡æãã©ã€ã¢ã«ãéå§ããŠãäœåãã®å³éžããããã¬ãã¢ã ã¹ããŒãªãŒã9,000 以äžã®éèªãæ°èã«ã¢ã¯ã»ã¹ããŠãã ããã
ãã§ã«è³Œèªè ã§ã? ãµã€ã³ã€ã³
WANNA UNWIND? HEAD TO JLN THIS WEEKEND & LET THE MUSIC PLAY!
HT City Unwind, India's biggest food and music festival, is back in Delhi with a curated line-up that's simply stellar
INDIAN CRAFT MEETS ITALIAN FLAIR: DIVIANA DEBUTS IN MILAN WITH A STARRY AFFAIR
In the prestigious Montenapoleone Fashion District of Milan, where luxury whispers through every cobblestone, DIVIANA has carved a niche as one of India's foremost luxury furniture brands.
Hanumankind joins A$AP Rocky on stage during Thailand concert
Rapper Hanumankind, the viral sensation from Kerala, recently performed on stage with rapper A$AP Rocky in Pattaya, Thailand.
Aditya: Emmy nom was enough, a win would.be cherry on top
It's heartening to see your work get recognised on such an international platform. But the biggest validation comes from the audience.
WEDDING BELLS FOR TAMANNAAH AND VIJAY? 'KYUN NAHIN?', SHE SAYS
The actor-couple is likely to take the plunge in 2025; Bhatia says she would continue to act even after marriageâ
India sizzle in sun, Australia scorched
Opener Jaiswalâs 161 and Kohliâs 30th Test century followed by the hostsâ batting tumble leave India eyeing a win in Perth
UN rules for carbon trading between nations approved
New rules allowing wealthy polluting countries to buy carbon-cutting \"offsets\" from developing nations were agreed at UN climate talks on Saturday, a move already raising fears they will be used to greenwash climate targets.
Earth bids farewell to its temporary 'mini moon'
Planet Earth is parting company with an asteroid that's been tagging along as a \"mini moon\" for the past two months.
Cops feted for rescuing 104 trafficked children
Delhi Police head constables Seema Devi and Suman Hooda were felicitated on Sunday with the inaugural Times Now Heroes award for helping rescue 104 trafficked children in nine months across three states and reuniting them with their families.
There's dearth of will to address climate crisis
The climate summit, COP29, in Baku, has ended. It lays bare the fundamental inequity and the lack of willingness of the developed world to acknowledge its role in climate change.