Questions unanswered - Inquiry offers insights - but may be missing crucial issues
The Guardian|October 25, 2024
During the two criminal trials of the nurse Lucy Letby, jurors were given a huge volume of complex evidence including tens of thousands of pages of medical notes, swipecard data, witness testimony, Facebook messages and more.
- Josh Halliday
Questions unanswered - Inquiry offers insights - but may be missing crucial issues

Letby, now 34, was found guilty of murdering seven babies and attempting to murder another seven on the neonatal unit of the Countess of Chester hospital in north-west England.

Those convictions are now the subject of intense debate.

Some experts have questioned the medical science and other evidence used in the trials. Yet four of Britain's most senior judges have ruled there are - at present - no grounds for appeal. A fresh legal challenge is being prepared by Letby's new barrister.

As concerns surrounding the convictions grow, a public inquiry is examining the events surrounding the spike in premature baby deaths at the hospital. It is not engaging with the question of whether the nurse is guilty in the first place.

Over the course of five weeks at Liverpool town hall, the inquiry under Lady Justice Thirlwall has uncovered new details about Letby, the neonatal unit on which she worked, and the shocking experiences of the bereaved families at the heart of this scandal.

For some, this new evidence - most of which was not heard during the criminal trials - will help explain how this young university-educated nurse was able, in the words of one detective, to "operate in plain sight".

To others, it may strengthen their belief that these tragic events had a more innocent explanation.

Here is what we have learned so far from the inquiry.

Letby's character
Jurors who sat through Letby's original 10-month trial were given only glimpses of her personality in the dock. None of her family, friends or colleagues who had stood by her took to the witness box to give evidence in her defence, so it was Letby herself who had to paint the picture. Her 14 days of testimony left many in court with more questions than answers.

この蚘事は The Guardian の October 25, 2024 版に掲茉されおいたす。

7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トラむアルを開始しお、䜕千もの厳遞されたプレミアム ストヌリヌ、9,000 以䞊の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしおください。

この蚘事は The Guardian の October 25, 2024 版に掲茉されおいたす。

7 日間の Magzter GOLD 無料トラむアルを開始しお、䜕千もの厳遞されたプレミアム ストヌリヌ、9,000 以䞊の雑誌や新聞にアクセスしおください。

THE GUARDIANのその他の蚘事すべお衚瀺
The Guardian

Peace deal

What will the agreement entail?

time-read
2 分  |
November 27, 2024
'I felt the scapegoat' Bellingham laments media treatment on England duty
The Guardian

'I felt the scapegoat' Bellingham laments media treatment on England duty

Jude Bellingham has said he felt the \"whole world crumbling down on me\" after being mistreated and made a scapegoat for England's defeat in the European Championship final.

time-read
2 分  |
November 27, 2024
The Guardian

United spent £8.6m sacking staff in drive to cut costs

Manchester United spent £8.6m on redundancies in the first quarter of its financial year due to Sir Jim Ratcliffe's drive to reduce the workforce from around 1,000 by 250, the club's latest accounts show.

time-read
1 min  |
November 27, 2024
The Guardian

Slot says contract dispute may be bringing best out of Salah

Khephren Thuram on his father Lilian's activism, what Thierry Henry always told him, and facing Aston Villa

time-read
2 分  |
November 27, 2024
Saka leads Arsenal's charge to blast away doubts on the road in Europe
The Guardian

Saka leads Arsenal's charge to blast away doubts on the road in Europe

This was some response to charges of being shot shy. Arsenal's lack of cutting edge on foreign trips had been the pre-match talking point but it turned out they had saved up a hiding for the continent's form team.

time-read
3 分  |
November 27, 2024
City stunned by late fightback as Guardiola's winless run goes on
The Guardian

City stunned by late fightback as Guardiola's winless run goes on

Manchester City's losing sequence is over - just. But they are still a listing ship that can go down at any moment.

time-read
3 分  |
November 27, 2024
Kerr breaks new ground coaching men at Hearts
The Guardian

Kerr breaks new ground coaching men at Hearts

Shelley Kerr will lead male player development at the Edinburgh club

time-read
1 min  |
November 27, 2024
'He's a cool cat' Special Bethell ready to pounce on Test debut
The Guardian

'He's a cool cat' Special Bethell ready to pounce on Test debut

Test debutant has impressed everyone from a young age but can he carry off batting at No 3 against New Zealand?

time-read
3 分  |
November 27, 2024
West Brom deny Isidor and hold out for draw
The Guardian

West Brom deny Isidor and hold out for draw

Sunderland extended their unbeaten run to 10 games but, as the smattering of gentle boos that greeted the final whistle testified, it was most certainly not a cause for celebration on Wearside.

time-read
2 分  |
November 27, 2024
George in the groove and ready to rock for England
The Guardian

George in the groove and ready to rock for England

Manchester United left-back was never going to let rehab end her dream and hopes for a Wembley bow against USA

time-read
2 分  |
November 27, 2024