However, data from World Rugby covering the main international and cross-border club competitions over the past year suggests it is no longer serving its purpose.
The common assumption that there is a seven-point net gain for the team who has the man advantage is wide of the mark.
In the last editions of the Rugby World Cup 2019, the Six Nations and The Rugby Championship there was only a two-point net swing during the ten minutes of the sin-bin, and in just over half the matches in Japan (51 per cent), there was no advantage at all.
Meanwhile, in the two European competitions, the Champions Cup and Challenge Cup, the net gain was twice as high but still less than the value of an unconverted try.
Former England head coach Brian Ashton believes this is an indictment not of the sin-bin itself but of the attacking skills and mindset of the team temporarily playing with 15 men against 14.
“If a team in ten minutes can’t get scores on the board playing against a man down, then you just wonder why they are even bothering to be honest,” said Ashton, below, now working in football as a coach mentor.
“It doesn’t mean the system should be changed, it is nothing to do with the system, it’s the people playing and coaching the game.
“You get odd flashes with odd teams who suddenly break free and try and play rugby and are confrontational – not just physical but in every way, mentally and tactically and technically as well.
“There are players dotted around the Premiership who can do that but by and large a lot of it, in my eyes anyway, is relatively predictable.
Denne historien er fra April 19, 2020-utgaven av The Rugby Paper.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent ? Logg på
Denne historien er fra April 19, 2020-utgaven av The Rugby Paper.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
Campese: Schmidt is wrong man for Aussies
DAVID Campese delivered a blunt message regarding Joe Schmidt’s position as Australia’s head coach, claiming the Kiwi isn’t right for the role because he doesn’t understand the Wallabies’ culture and history.
How London Welsh are working way back to top
William Gupwell goes down to south-west London to find a club out to rediscover itself
Sorry, Geoff, but let's not de-power scrums
EVERY week I can’t wait for Sunday to come around so that I can read The Rugby Paper and see what is really happening in our game.
Howdy! England pair saddle up to spread the word
JESS Breach and Ellie Kildunne have launched their new podcast Rugby Rodeo with one ambition in mind – to grow the profile of the women’s game.
I put in three good shots on Jonah Lomu
BACK in the day, when we first started in Leagues in 1987, we began in North East 2.
Dupont & Co need to take on the very best
I THINK we established long ago that my admiration of Antoine Dupont knows no bounds, he is the best rugby player I have ever reported on or watched in the flesh, pipping Gareth Edwards by a short head, but there is no question that there is a gaping huge hole in his CV which many cite against him when the all-time lists are compiled and debated.
Tuipulotu's power is too much for Cardiff
SCOTLAND star Sione Tuipulotu has been hailed as one of the best three 12s in the world following his player of the match display in this 13-try rollercoaster at the Arms Park.
Following in father's footsteps ... but for how long?
CAST your minds back, those of you who are sufficiently long in the tooth, to Melbourne in late October 2003.
Borthwick should call up these young props
IT WAS surprising that neither of England’s U20 world champion props, Asher Opoku-Fordjour (Sale) or Afolabi Fasogbon (Gloucester), were in the England training squad going to Portugal ahead of the autumn series.
Lively Reed lights the spark to ignite Sharks
AARON Reed proved to be Sale’s pivotal weapon, and the perfect foil in both attack and defence to ensure Sharks came out on the right side of a nine-try nailbiter on Friday.