IN HIS SEMINAL BOOK Street Level Bureaucracy: Dilemmas of the Individual in Public Services, Michael Lipsky extensively wrote about the discretionary powers of street-level bureaucrats. "The essence of street-level bureaucracies is that they require people to make decisions about others. Street-level bureaucrats have discretion because the nature of service provision calls for human judgment that cannot be programmed and for which machines cannot substitute". For Lipsky, the decisions made by these "over-burdened" bureaucrats were "ad-hoc policy adaptations that impacted people's lives". However, if one looks at the non-street level bureaucracy and, for that matter, the political executive in the state, the exercise of discretionary powers has not always been for good. Discretionary powers can sometimes be very detrimental to both the ease of doing business and the ease of living. Urbanisation in India has also been held hostage by discretionary powers, be they those of the street-level bureaucrats or the state government.
For instance, in the 1990s, the state government of Tamil Nadu created the Tamil Nadu Slum Clearance Board (TNSCB) to address the problem of slums in the state's capital, Chennai. The TNSCB had the discretionary powers to acquire land, demolish slums, and rehabilitate slum dwellers. However, as always, the discretionary powers were not exercised uniformly. Some slums were destroyed without proper provision of rehabilitation, and selective enforcement led to accusations of corruption and partiality. Many slum dwellers were displaced without adequate warning or compensation, and some became homeless as a result. We have explained in these pages earlier how states fail to notify something like census towns as urban. However, one often doesn't discuss the urgent need for land reforms.
Denne historien er fra February 11, 2023-utgaven av Businessworld India.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent ? Logg på
Denne historien er fra February 11, 2023-utgaven av Businessworld India.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
Gauging Trumponomics For India
Despite some shortto mediumterm headwinds in trade and immigration, the broader Indo-US vision of counterbalancing China’s influence is expected to ensure continued cooperation under Trump 2.0
Reflections on Consciousness and Creation
Indian-American DEEPAK CHOPRA on the nature of the universe, the digital fabric of existence, and the power of a conscious mind
MORE TAKE TO DRIVING IN STYLE
High-end luxury vehicles are no longer part of a niche market, but a rapidly expanding segment of automobile sales, driven by changing consumer preferences, rising disposable incomes and better infrastructure
India's Growing Affinity for Swiss Watches: A Luxury on the Rise
NDIA'S ROBUST ECONOMIC growth, projected to exceed 6 per cent in 2024 and 2025, is fostering a rising demand for aspirational products. As disposable incomes increase, particularly among the expanding middle class, luxury goods such as Swiss-made watches are gaining popularity.
An ENRiching Outlook
KPMG's latest report shows energy CEOs being optimistic about the sector's outlook. ANISH DE, Global Head, ENRC, KPMG speaks to BW Businessworld's Arjun Yadav on what's driving this confidence
Paving the Path to a Sustainable Future
Salesforce's ESG journey has made an impact beyond the company. SUNYA NORMAN, SVP of ESG Strategy and Engagement at Salesforce, shares more on how the tech giant integrates sustainability into its core operations, supporting global goals while empowering employees
LEADERSHIP TRANSITION AT XIAOMI INDIA
Xiaomi India is experiencing a leadership evolution, beginning with Muralikrishnan B's departure as President by the end of 2024. This change underscores Xiaomi's shift towards nurturing local talent amidst dynamic global shifts. The story tracks key transitions from Manu Kumar Jain's leadership to Muralikrishnan B's impactful tenure, along with recent strategic hires, highlighting Xiaomi's alignment towards market adaptability and consumer focus
WEAVING SUSTAINABILITY
Once a modest home textile manufacturer, Jindal Worldwide has evolved into a vertically integrated textile powerhouse, spanning critical segments of the yarn and fabric value chain
FORCE FOR GOOD
FY24 saw capacity expansions for Century Enka in nylon and polyester segments, along with investments in modernisation, renewable energy, and safety initiatives
REIMAGINING TOMORROW
For V-Guard, tomorrow signifies progress, driven by today's actions, setting the foundation for future growth and value creation for all stakeholders