Why was Stuart England seen as a 'failed state' by its European counterparts?
One argument that attracted particular attention in my recent book, Devil-Land: England Under Siege 1588-1688, was the claim that "to contemporaries and foreigners alike, 17th century England was a failed state: a discomfiting byword for seditious rebellion, religious extremism and regime change." It was part of the book's emphasis on Stuart England's characteristic insecurity, instability and vulnerability, which is also reflected in its title. The nickname ‘Duyvel-Landt’, or ‘Devil-Land’ was applied to mid-17th century England by an anonymous Dutch pamphleteer in 1652, who had been outraged by the English Parliament’s decision to put on trial and publicly execute its divinely ordained king, Charles I, while the successor republican regime seemed to declare war on the Dutch Republic as commercial rivals.
In this context, it was a deliberately polemical and provocative claim, and anachronistic or insensitive parallels with current affairs are unhelpful. Today, there are clear metrics and databased policy tools deployed to measure ‘failed states’. But, in 1652, when that Dutch pamphleteer described England as ‘Devil-Land’, the country had been bitterly divided by civil war for over a decade; brothers had taken up arms against one another for either King or Parliament; countless wartime atrocities had occurred, including premeditated massacres; and, in Ireland, extensive ethnic cleansing had occurred. After Charles I’s regicide in January 1649, England underwent no less than five major regime changes in a decade with more minor revolutions and constitutional experiments before Charles II was restored in 1660.
Denne historien er fra Issue 132-utgaven av All About History UK.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent ? Logg på
Denne historien er fra Issue 132-utgaven av All About History UK.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
THE MINISTRY OF UNGENTLEMANLY WARFARE
Guy Ritchie's entertaining WWII thriller throws light on Operation Postmaster
SURVIVING A FINANCIAL CRISIS
Jame DiBiasio explores how financiers can learn from the mistakes of the past
FORT KNOX BULLION DEPOSITORY
United States 1937-present
MUSSOLINI HAD JOINED THE ALLIES?
Driven by ambition, Italy's participation in the Axis war effort led to the collapse of its empire, the fall of the Fascist Party and Mussolini's death Interview
BATTLE OF DETTINGEN
DETTINGEN (MODERN-DAY KARLSTEIN AM MAIN, GERMANY), 27 JUNE 1743
THE USSR's FAKE OLYMPICS,
Having boycotted the 1984 games in Los Angeles, the Soviet Union hosted its own competition
Hürrem Sultan
From slave girl to imperial consort, how one girl captured the heart of an emperor to become the most powerful woman in Ottoman history
OVERTHROWING THE MONGOLS
How a Buddhist rebellion toppled the mighty empire and began the rise of the Ming dynasty Written
MAKING A MONSTER
Natalie Lawrence explores the creation of enchanted creatures through 15,000 years of history Interview
SECRETS OF THE PYRAMIDS
From sacred rituals to hidden treasure, uncover why these world wonders were built