Three senior judges agreed with them that 'owner funding, like state aid, is subsidisation.
'That is particularly so when other sources of external funding are not permitted! However, they subsequently concluded that it was unlawful to exclude shareholder loans from Profitability and Sustainability Regulations when the same treatment was not afforded to APTs and it was classed as an object infringement of competition law.
"An object infringement is the most serious sort of grievance. It means that you don't actually have to do a detailed dive on the impact of that infringement," Jack Williams, a barrister in competition law at Monckton Chambers told M.E.N.Sport.
"If you look at it, you go, this is just wrong. The tribunal found it was just wrong - this is a big deal in competition law terms.
"They didn't have to go through loads of economic analysis. It's dressed up over 175 pages but they've basically looked at these terms and decided they are discriminatory and unlawful.
Denne historien er fra October 09, 2024-utgaven av Manchester Evening News.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent ? Logg på
Denne historien er fra October 09, 2024-utgaven av Manchester Evening News.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
Small-time United show true colours with another backward step
RUBEN Amorim slumped his shoulders in the 57th minute. Three minutes later, his body language worsened. This week was as huge as the Arsenal and Liverpool weeks. This was another backward step for a club that is seemingly incapable of moving forwards. This small-time United side has shown its true colours.
Village restaurant set for move after staff struggles
ONE of Manchester's best restaurants is to close its eatery in Prestwich. The Scandinavian-influenced, Michelin-rated restaurant OSMA has been a feature of the village since it opened in 2020. Its owners have announced its final day of service will be Sunday, February 9 ahead of a move to an un-named Manchester city centre location.
TOONE HITS HAT-TRICK IN DERBY WIN FOR REDS
A HAT-TRICK by Ella Toone helped United stun City by a 4-2 score to leapfrog their rivals in the Women's Super League.
Date set for Ruud return in cup clash with Foxes
RUUD van Nistelrooy will return to Old Trafford for the first time since leaving the club next month, with the date for United's FA Cup fourth round clash against Leicester City confirmed.
BRU RUES 'LACK OF CONFIDENCE' IN UNITED SIDE
BRUNO Fernandes has admitted that United's players are currently experiencing a 'lack of confidence' after being beaten 3-1 by Brighton at Old Trafford yesterday.
May's stroke recovery
ACTRESS Anita Dobson has said her husband Sir Brian May is \"stable\" and they are \"taking each day as it comes\" following his stroke last year.
'We should be more than the place with the man with a paper mache head'
RESIDENTS HAVE THEIR SAY AMID PUSH FOR IMPROVEMENTS TO SUBURB
What are social media platforms doing about it?
TIKTOK told us the sale of drugs on the platform violates their Community Guidelines. They added they have tens of thousands of safety professionals dedicated to keeping Tik Tok safe and continue to invest in strengthening their enforcement strategies.
Guardiola has faith his side are on the road to recovery
PEP Guardiola believes City are edging closer to their best after a fluent performance saw them dismantle Ipswich at Portman Road to climb back into the Premier League top four.
£86m misfit Ant sure Bet for loan to a Spanish club
UNITED are preparing for Antony to leave on loan before the winter transfer window closes. There is a growing belief that the winger will secure a loan for the remainder of the season before deadline day on February 3, with Real Betis interested in Antony.
