When it comes to electoral reform, Labour is politely but completely divided. The members are hugely keen, with 140 local parties submitting the motion that was passed in 2022. The leadership could barely be less interested.
And even though FPTP has just delivered Keir Starmer a big Commons majority, some in the party wonder whether the relatively shaky foundations of this mighty victory necessitate a rethink on electoral reform, if not immediately then before too long.
Sandy Martin, a former MP who now chairs the Labour Campaign for Electoral Reform, said thinking about a move to PR "should be a priority" for the party, despite the way it benefited so handsomely from the current system.
"It would only take Reform and the Conservatives to unite and they might have a majority on the same scale we had this year," he said. "But under PR, Labour would most likely be able to form a government quite comfortably with the Liberal Democrats or the Greens, and this would be preferable to a ConservativeReform government."
As well as self-interest, Martin said, FPTP felt increasingly inappropriate when only 58% of votes went to the two main parties: "In England we now have five parties, and in Scotland and Wales you have six. You can't run a first past the post system - where one party is basically trying to beat the other party - when you've got five or six parties to play with."
Denne historien er fra July 17, 2024-utgaven av The Guardian.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent ? Logg på
Denne historien er fra July 17, 2024-utgaven av The Guardian.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
Madueke and Palmer show there is hope for Chelsea project
Chelsea's business planning and human resource practices may confound all but their blue-sky thinkers, but that does not preclude them providing great entertainment.
Evolving England have youthful appeal for 'grandad' Root
Former captain is enjoying life in the ranks as Brendon McCullum's team show they can win in a different style
Manufacturers renew calls for UK industrial strategy
UK manufacturers have renewed calls on the government to urgently draft an industrial strategy that will bring in investment and fix the \"terrible\" damage caused by the Brexit deal.
'Everyone was afraid' DRC's displaced families caught on the mpox frontline
First, liquid-filled blisters developed on threeyear-old Marceline Désiré's back.
RFK Jr's sibling 'heartbroken' over Trump endorsement
Max Kennedy, the brother of Robert F Kennedy Jr, has implored the public to ignore his sibling's decision to drop out of the 2024 presidential election and endorse Donald Trump.
Von der Leyen expected to miss gender target for senior EU jobs
Ursula von der Leyen is expected to miss her target of a gender-balanced European Commission, after EU governments snubbed her request to propose male and female candidates.
Solingen stabbings suspect motivated by ideology of Islamic State, prosecutors say
Prosecutors have said the suspect arrested over a stabbing rampage in the western German city of Solingen shares the radical ideology of the Islamic State and was acting on those beliefs when he launched his attack.
Fear in Venezuela Maduro seeks to cement third term as 1,600 detainees languish in cells
Nicolás Maduro calls his political crackdown Operación Tun Tun (Operation Knock Knock) after the spine-chilling visits his security forces pay their targets.
Women abused as children could be denied justice due to legal anomaly
Thousands of women who were sexually abused as children could be unable to obtain justice because of an anomaly in the law of England and Wales that is being challenged at the European court of human rights.
Protection for asylum seekers in hotels needed urgently, Cooper warned
More than 50 refugee organisations have written to the home secretary calling for urgent protections to be put in place for asylum seekers living in hotels who may be at risk from further far-right attacks.
