There are lots of bad arguments for ending the universal winter fuel payment to all pensioners - if we don't fill the fiscal black hole left by the Tories, the markets will punish us the way they did Liz Truss - but there are also some good ones.
The UK debate on this is hopelessly confused. Those who argue that it can't possibly make sense for the government to hand out non-means-tested benefits like winter fuel payments to rich pensioners rarely confront the logic of their arguments, which is to also means-test the state pension, not to mention to charge those who can afford to pay for universal services, such as the NHS.
Quite apart from the political and practical obstacles, there are extremely good economic reasons against this. Means-testing the state pension would effectively destroy any incentive to save for vast swathes of lower and middle-income workers.
But equally, those who argue against means-testing, either on principle or because of its undoubted drawbacks – that some recipients find it stigmatising, others will inevitably slip through the net, and that it requires a complex, expensive and sometimes intrusive bureaucratic process to administer – are equally unrealistic.
Paying a universal pension at a level that would lift all pensioners out of poverty (even, for example, those with high housing costs or energy bills) would require very large increases to the basic pensions, inevitably meaning higher taxes for workers.
Denne historien er fra September 11, 2024-utgaven av The Independent.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent ? Logg på
Denne historien er fra September 11, 2024-utgaven av The Independent.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
'Fight days are for fighting, not chatting to each other'
This Saturday, Joshua Buatsi will share a card with his friend Anthony Joshua for the fourth time, boxing Willy Hutchinson for an interim title at Wembley. Alex Pattle gets the lowdown
F1 title opening could prove to be Norris's only chance
Under the afternoon sun on Saturday in the Azerbaijani capital of Baku, it felt like the moment the drivers’ title slipped away from Lando Norris.
The Man City hearing must answer these two questions
Amid all of the uncertainty around the Manchester City investigation, there is one view that can be stated with confidence as it finally gets under way.
Super clubs have nothing to fear from Uefa's shake-up
As a new Champions League format makes its debut today, Miguel Delaney looks at what it means for the competition
Final messages from Titan before implosion revealed
“All good here.”
New Zealand's bird of the year picked up by a penguin
A rare, smelly and yellow-eyed penguin species has been crowned New Zealand’s bird of the year for the second time in less than a decade.
Death toll rises as floods devastate central Europe
The death toll across central Europe from the worst flooding in decades has risen to at least 16 after Storm Boris brought a month’s worth of rain in just 24 hours.
Germany reimposes border controls to tackle migration
Germany has reintroduced checks on all nine of its land borders in a move that has angered a number of its neighbours – but brought praise from the far right.
Putin boosts troop numbers as missiles pummel Ukraine
President Vladimir Putin yesterday ordered the regular size of the Russian army to increase by 180,000 troops to 1.5 million soldiers, the third time he has expanded its ranks since sending the military into Ukraine in February 2022.
'I figured he must be either dead or in prison by now...'
Those who know Ryan Routh talk of his previous 'escapades'