LONDON The International Court of Justice’s ICJ) ruling on accusations that Israel is engaged in state-led genocide” in its military operations against Hamas in Gaza amounts to a legal triumph for South Africa, which brought the case before the world court.
But the decisive victory” claimed by South Africa is on a finer point of international law and may have little practical impact on the conduct of the Gaza war.
The court’s panel of 17 judges decided by substantial majorities that the risk of genocide as the act of the deliberate and wholesale murder of an entire ethnic or religious group is defined in international law exists in Gaza and that South Africa’s accusations are at least plausible even though they remain unproven for the moment.
The court, which will take years to examine the substance of the charges, also accepted South Africa’s argument that immediate measures should be taken to address the current Gaza wat.
The ruling means that Israel failed in its plea that the court should dismiss the entire matter.
However, Israel’s legal defeat is less significant than it currently seems.
The judges did not order a ceasefire in the Gaza war, as demanded by South Africa, nor did they direct Israel to stop its bombing.
The ICJ only instructed Israel to take every measure in its power to prevent military operations that could lead to genocide and to report to the ICJ on such measures.
The court’s interim ruling bore all the hallmarks of a very carefully drafted decision, written in the full knowledge it would have historical importance.
Denne historien er fra January 27, 2024-utgaven av The Straits Times.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent ? Logg på
Denne historien er fra January 27, 2024-utgaven av The Straits Times.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
VERDY'S APPROACH AN EYE-OPENER
Former Lions turned coaches Alam Shah and Isa inspired by stint with Japanese club
Lions' morale-boosting win comes at a price
The Lions got a much-needed morale booster ahead of the Asean Football Federation (AFF) Championship as they beat Tokyo Verdy 2-1 on Oct 11 in the second of three friendlies against J1 League opponents in their Japan training tour.
Conditions to blame for 'ugly' draw, says Messi
Argentina were held to a 1-1 draw by Venezuela on Lionel Messi's return, as Brazil got their 2026 World Cup qualifying campaign back on track with a last-gasp 2-1 victory over Chile on Oct 10.
Belgium punish Italy at set pieces in 2-2 draw
Italy coach Luciano Spalletti blamed bad luck, as Belgium bounced back from two goals down to draw 2-2 with his 10-man side in Rome on Oct 10 to boost their hopes of reaching the Nations League quarter-finals.
CARSLEY'S MIDFIELD OVERLOAD BACKFIRES
England temp boss dismayed by mistakes as Three Lions lose to Greece for first time
Player strike in England unlikely: Sports law expert
The chorus of frustrated players and managers speaking out against football's gruelling fixture schedule continues to grow, with Liverpool defender Ibrahima Konate the latest to say he would support players' right to strike.
SOCCEROOS HAVE NO FEAR
They head to Japan with confidence despite never having beaten the Samurai Blue there
Toyota back in F1 with Haas tie-up
The United States-owned Haas Formula One team and Toyota announced a multi-year technical partnership on Oct 11, in a move bringing Japan's biggest carmaker back to grand prix racing for the first time since 2009.
SABALENKA TO STICK TO HER BRAVE PLAN
World No. 2 will be aggressive in Wuhan semi against Gauff; Fritz takes on Djokovic
Nadal's beauty lay in his purity as a competitor
To appreciate the retiring Rafael Nadal we can flip through record books, hunt down Uncle Toni, sift the clay for archaeological clues, speak to Roger Federer's therapist, delve into the physics of spin, but really it's best if we start with a dictionary.