Mr Lee is a 70-year-old ex-teacher with diabetes and mild dementia. He lived alone and was hospitalised after a giddy spell due to low blood sugar caused him to fall. It likely happened because he ate erratically and would sometimes double dose on his diabetes medication on account of memory lapses.
Although he was able to navigate his neighbourhood and manage simple finances before he was hospitalised, Mr Lee frequently felt giddy and fell often at home. His only relative was a sister who visited him once a month.
It was deemed unsafe for him to continue living by himself and that he'd be better off in a nursing home.
On hearing this, Mr Lee dug in his heels and demanded immediate discharge from the hospital. He appeared to appreciate the risks of living alone but prioritised his freedom over safety.
But when asked about his long-term plans to ensure his continued well-being, Mr Lee could not give a definitive answer. Therein lies the conundrum. If it is assessed that Mr Lee possesses adequate mental capacity to make an informed decision, should he be allowed to go home and risk further mishaps which may even threaten his life?
On the other hand, if it is determined that he lacks mental capacity, should his wishes be thwarted, and he be institutionalised against his will?
Can we seek a solution that balances respect for his wishes to live at home, and secure his safety and well-being at the same time?
Persons living with dementia face complex care and medical needs that warrant carefully considered decisions. When confronted with such decisions, these people are assessed on their mental capacity to make informed choices. Otherwise, healthcare professionals, donees or legal guardians will act in their best interests.
The problem arises when those deemed to possess mental capacity make decisions that are detrimental to themselves, while those who lack mental capacity have unwelcome decisions imposed upon them.
Denne historien er fra September 26, 2024-utgaven av The Straits Times.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent ? Logg på
Denne historien er fra September 26, 2024-utgaven av The Straits Times.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
Krupnova brings positivity to Wondersticks and S'pore
While it has been only two weeks since Eliska Krupnova joined Singapore Floorball Premier League (SFL) side Wondersticks, the 2020 world's best female floorball player has lit up the league in more ways than one.
HER UNFINISHED BUSINESS
Belarusian Goutseva back to complete her artistic swimming vision for Singapore
Villa now in the big leagues, thanks to their manager
On The Ball | There are doubts about the new Champions League format, its extended group stage and \"Swiss model\" fixture list. Try telling that to anyone connected with Aston Villa, though.
REDS' WIN 'SPECIAL' FOR SLOT
Manager says it will let wife see a happy man, but warns of tough stretch ahead
Respectful Emery wary of United's winning mentality
Unai Emery praised the under-pressure Erik ten Hag on Oct 4 as the Aston Villa boss labelled Manchester United \"the best team in the world\" despite their dismal form.
ANGE FACES A 'CURIOUS' TEST BY HURZELER
Brighton boss, who asked 'many questions' on a day at Spurs in 2023, has 'inside info'
Pogba's 'nightmare is over' as ban cut to 18 months
French international footballer Paul Pogba said on Oct 4 that his \"nightmare is over\" after a four-year ban for doping was reduced to 18 months.
Blues need time to compete with City, Arsenal
Chelsea are improving but are not yet ready to compete with top English Premier League clubs like Manchester City and Arsenal, manager Enzo Maresca said on Oct 4.
Billie Jean King Cup to align with Davis Cup format
The Billie Jean King Cup Finals will transition to an eight-team event in 2025, from the current 12, to mirror the existing Davis Cup format, the International Tennis Federation (ITF) said on Oct 4.
Money talks to grow US rugby reportedly back on
Rugby union's governing body World Rugby has revived talks to raise funds for growing the sport in the United States, three people familiar with the matter said.