What About Murder?
Mystery Scene|Summer #168 2021
Reference Books Reviewed
Jon L. Breen
What About Murder?

Thomson, David

Murder and the Movies New Haven: Yale University Press, 2020. 241pp. Index. $26, ebook $12.99

The author, a prolific historian and commentator on film, says his original title for this book was Murder at the Movies, which suggests a much lighter survey. The one-word change was appropriate. This book reflects a very dark view of present-day society and where we seem to be heading. It begins with David Thomson and his co-viewer enthusiastically enumerating the murders in the excellent Netflix series Ozark, quickly finding at least 11 in the first season alone. The game sounds like fun for a while, but it leads into the questions that drive the discussion to come: Why are we willing to absorb and celebrate so many visual homicides? What does it say about our society, values, gender attitudes, and our own capacity to murder?

Among the movies considered at some length are the screen adaptations of Rogue Male, East of Eden, The Godfather, French and American versions of The Talented Mr. Ripley, Silence of the Lambs, Kind Hearts and Coronets, M, Blow Up, The Manchurian Candidate, Fatal Attraction, Gone Girl, Double Indemnity, Targets, Taxi Driver, The Big Sleep (with a pointed comparison to the much darker Raymond Chandler novel), LA Confidential, and several Woody Allen films.

Unsurprisingly, Alfred Hitchcock’s name comes up more than any other. An extended survey of murders in his films concentrates on his complicated relationship to actresses and the characters they play. He is compared and contrasted with his contemporary Agatha Christie: both English, both associated with murder as subject matter, but of different social classes and very different in their approaches.

This story is from the Summer #168 2021 edition of Mystery Scene.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the Summer #168 2021 edition of Mystery Scene.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM MYSTERY SCENEView All
6 New Writers to Watch
Mystery Scene

6 New Writers to Watch

Wiley Cash’s debut, A Land More Kind Than Home, about the bond between two brothers landed on the New York Times Best Sellers List and received the Crime Writers’ Association Debut of the Year.

time-read
10 mins  |
Fall #169, 2021
ANN CLEEVES
Mystery Scene

ANN CLEEVES

British author Ann Cleeves has an affinity for remote areas and how these isolated regions affect her characters.

time-read
10+ mins  |
Fall #169, 2021
CARLENE O'CONNOR
Mystery Scene

CARLENE O'CONNOR

“Anyone can play Snow White. It takes real talent to play the Wicked Witch.”

time-read
8 mins  |
Fall #169, 2021
Mystery Scene MISCELLANY
Mystery Scene

Mystery Scene MISCELLANY

FIRST USE OF FINGERPRINTS

time-read
3 mins  |
Fall #169, 2021
PANIC ATTACK
Mystery Scene

PANIC ATTACK

The newest entry in my Pittsburgh set series of thrillers is called Panic Attack. It’s the sixth book featuring Daniel Rinaldi, a psychologist and trauma expert who consults with the Pittsburgh Police.

time-read
2 mins  |
Fall #169, 2021
LAIDLAW'S LEGACY
Mystery Scene

LAIDLAW'S LEGACY

During the pandemic, Ian Rankin stepped away from Rebus and into the shoes of friend and literary hero, the “Godfather of Tartan Noir” William McIlvanney.

time-read
10+ mins  |
Fall #169, 2021
HILARY DAVIDSON
Mystery Scene

HILARY DAVIDSON

Call it The Case of Life Imitating Art.

time-read
7 mins  |
Fall #169, 2021
Thomas Walsh - The Unusual Suspect
Mystery Scene

Thomas Walsh - The Unusual Suspect

Any paternity test on the sub-genre of police procedural will identify the DNA of Ed McBain and Lawrence Treat, as well as the 1948 movie The Naked City and the radio and TV series Dragnet…and of course Thomas Walsh.

time-read
6 mins  |
Fall #169, 2021
S.A. COSBY
Mystery Scene

S.A. COSBY

In Razorblade Tears, two aging men—one Black, one white, both with criminal pasts—join forces to seek revenge for the murders of their gay sons. The themes of fathers and sons and toxic masculinity will be familar to fans of Cosby’s 2020 breakout Blacktop Wasteland.

time-read
10 mins  |
Fall #169, 2021
VIPER'S NEST OF LIES
Mystery Scene

VIPER'S NEST OF LIES

A slip of the tongue is a dangerous thing. Not only does it expose indiscretions, it also can lead to murder. The latter especially applies to me.

time-read
2 mins  |
Fall #169, 2021