The Inhumanity Of Trump's 'Toughness'
New York magazine|June 25, 2018

For a would-be strongman, cruelty is the ultimate deterrent.

Jonathan Chait
The Inhumanity Of Trump's 'Toughness'

WHEN DONALD TRUMP first proposed to ban all Muslim immigrants from the United States two and a half years and a thousand Trump controversies ago, the Republican frontrunner was asked if he would have supported the internment of Japanese-Americans during World War II. “I would have had to be there at the time to tell you, to give you a proper answer,” he equivocated, before proceeding to express his general sympathy for the concept. “It’s a tough thing. It’s tough,” he said. “But you know, war is tough. And winning is tough. We don’t win anymore. We don’t win wars anymore. We don’t win wars anymore. We’re not a strong country anymore.”

One of the things this comment revealed was Trump’s odd belief that the internment of loyal Japanese-Americans had somehow helped win the war, rather than divert human and material resources from the war effort in service to a cruel, racialized panic, as historians generally believe. More was at work here than simple confusion. This historical digression proved to be a prophetic guide to an as-yet unimaginable future Trump presidency. It displayed one of Trump’s foundational values: his contempt for human and legal rights, especially those of racial minorities, and his atavistic fixation with toughness as both the source of the country’s (imagined) historical decline and the key to its restoration.

The Trump presidency is a surreal experience in part because it is so difficult to discern the reliability of the president’s rhetoric as a guide to action. The family separation crisis is an important moment in Trump’s presidency because it collapses the chasm between word and deed. The brutal vision of the American state Trump has been painting for three years has finally materialized before our eyes.

This story is from the June 25, 2018 edition of New York magazine.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the June 25, 2018 edition of New York magazine.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM NEW YORK MAGAZINEView All
A Wonk in Full- Ezra Klein, glowed-up and post-coup, was almost a celebrity at the convention.
New York magazine

A Wonk in Full- Ezra Klein, glowed-up and post-coup, was almost a celebrity at the convention.

Ezra Klein, glowed-up and post-coup, was almost a celebrity at the convention. Ezra Klein, who is known to keep his passions in check, did not have the right credentials to get into the arena. The Secret Service didn't recognize the New York Times' star "Opinion" writer and podcaster, but eventually he was able to figure out how to get in to where he belonged. This was, after all, as much his convention as any journalist's, since its high-energy optimism turned on the fact that President Joe Biden was no longer leading the ticket and, starting early this year, Klein had led the coup drumbeat.

time-read
5 mins  |
August 26 - September 08, 2024
The Afterlife of Donald Trump - The presidential hopeful contemplates his campaign, his formidable new opponent, and the miracle of his continued existence.
New York magazine

The Afterlife of Donald Trump - The presidential hopeful contemplates his campaign, his formidable new opponent, and the miracle of his continued existence.

Donald Trump raised his right hand and grabbed hold of it. He bent it backward and forward. I asked if I could take a closer look. These days, the former president and current triple threat-convicted felon, Republican presidential nominee, and recent survivor of an assassination attempt-comes from a place of yes. He waved me over to where he sat on this August afternoon, in a low-to-the-ground chair upholstered in cream brocade fabric in the grand living room at Mar-a-Lago.

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 09 - 22, 2024
Danzy Senna Can't Stop Thinking in Black and White
New York magazine

Danzy Senna Can't Stop Thinking in Black and White

Her latest novel holds diminishing returns.

time-read
6 mins  |
September 09 - 22, 2024
Live, Laugh, Love
New York magazine

Live, Laugh, Love

Dick jokes meet sentimentality in a wily Sandler-Safdie collab.

time-read
4 mins  |
September 09 - 22, 2024
Tim Burton Is Great Again
New York magazine

Tim Burton Is Great Again

A long-awaited sequel revels in gore and nostalgia.

time-read
4 mins  |
September 09 - 22, 2024
In the Shack With Robert Caro
New York magazine

In the Shack With Robert Caro

The Power Broker is turning 50. The final LBJ book is almostwell, he won't say exactly, but he's trying for 900 words a day.

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 09 - 22, 2024
24 Comedians You Should Know RIGHT NOW
New York magazine

24 Comedians You Should Know RIGHT NOW

THE COMEDY industry is undergoing a metamorphosis in 2024. Name-brand venues like the Second City and UCB are opening or reopening in New York, beloved local spots are being bought out by megacorporations, and streaming-service-helmed comedy festivals are usurping the old-fashioned ones. Post-WGA strike, TV-development execs are growing green-light-shy, Hulu is entering the stand-up fray, and YouTube specials are becoming just as worthy of watching as Netflix specials, if not more so.

time-read
9 mins  |
September 09 - 22, 2024
Leading Lady
New York magazine

Leading Lady

Anna Sawai could take home the Emmy for her performance in Shogun. But she's keeping her cool.

time-read
8 mins  |
September 09 - 22, 2024
RESTAURANT REVIEW: Le Même Veau
New York magazine

RESTAURANT REVIEW: Le Même Veau

The Frenchette crew has taken over the 87-year-old restaurant, and the snails are as garlicky and the duck as pink as ever.

time-read
3 mins  |
September 09 - 22, 2024
DESIGN HUNTING: A LOFT WITH A HIGHER PURPOSE
New York magazine

DESIGN HUNTING: A LOFT WITH A HIGHER PURPOSE

Ali Richmond, co-founder of the nonprofit Fashion for All Foundation, has lived in this Brooklyn loft for almost 20 years with his archive of designer clothing.

time-read
3 mins  |
September 09 - 22, 2024