Fit For Purpose
Sporting Shooter|February 2018
Can you work a trialling dog in the beating line? Is one job different from the other, and should you train them the same way? Ryan Kay gives his view on this much debated subject
Ryan Kay
Fit For Purpose

I regularly have new customers turn up for a lesson with a firm requisite in mind, a clear picture of what they want to achieve with their dog and what they will be using it for. And that’s just perfect, because my first question at the start of a lesson always is: what is your end goal?

Until we know what the end goal is, we have nothing to aim for. Some owners are quite particular and already have a clear and unblemished image of what their dog should be doing once it’s trained, with an exact discipline within the shooting field in mind. So if the request is a ‘peg dog’ then a peg dog we will aim for, with no diversifying! And that’s good, I like that. It means I can be black and white with the instructions and the dog can receive black and white training – which is always what a dog wants.

However, I find that the majority of us, and indeed most new clients who turn up, want the dog to step in and out of several disciplines – peg dog one day, hunting dog the next, picking-up the day after: an all-rounder. And with that demand, a nonchalant explanation of what is desired sometimes arrives with the owner, one that often contradicts itself.

It goes a little like this: “I don’t want a trialling dog, Ryan, I just want it to hunt nicely in front of me, stop when I blow the whistle and retrieve when I say so!”

“That is a trialling dog,” I reply.

“No, no… I just want it to find game for me, not hunt too far in front and come back when I whistle it… you know, something I can shoot over and go beating with.”

Again: “A trialling dog then?!”

What they usually mean is they’re not looking to train the dog to a trialling standard. I do recognise that, but it suggests that already we’re happy to settle for flaky or sub-standard dog work.

This story is from the February 2018 edition of Sporting Shooter.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the February 2018 edition of Sporting Shooter.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM SPORTING SHOOTERView All
RSPB gives mixed message on shooting
Sporting Shooter

RSPB gives mixed message on shooting

Having recently attended the RSPB’s virtual AGM, Conor O’Gorman discusses the outcome of the charity’s year-long review of game bird shooting

time-read
2 mins  |
December 2020
Causeway for concern
Sporting Shooter

Causeway for concern

Alan Jarrett’s renewed interest in reading takes him down memory lane to an offshore island duck flight that very nearly ended in disaster

time-read
4 mins  |
December 2020
Through a purple patch
Sporting Shooter

Through a purple patch

The Garrows Estate is taking a conservation-focused approach to restoring the wildlife populations and biodiversity on the Scottish heather moorland.

time-read
8 mins  |
December 2020
When the wheels fall off
Sporting Shooter

When the wheels fall off

Losing form on a day’s shooting can be infuriating, especially if you’ve been shooting like a god up to that point. Simon O’Leary looks at some common causes and how to remedy them

time-read
4 mins  |
December 2020
Beaches, books & bad behaviour!
Sporting Shooter

Beaches, books & bad behaviour!

The annual Kay family vacation to Northumberland offers a chance to give the cockers a blast on the beach – although they don’t always shower themselves in glory, as Ryan Kay recalls...

time-read
7 mins  |
December 2020
Using the Stop whistle
Sporting Shooter

Using the Stop whistle

Now you’ve instilled the basics, it’s time to up the ante with some more tricky distance work. Howard Kirby explains how to take the core Stop whistle command to the next level

time-read
5 mins  |
December 2020
The humble teal
Sporting Shooter

The humble teal

They may be tiny, but as far as Rupert Butler is concerned, the appeal of this little duck is huge. He recalls some of his most memorable nights in pursuit of these aerial acrobats

time-read
4 mins  |
December 2020
Fab all-rounder
Sporting Shooter

Fab all-rounder

Mike is impressed with the Fabarm Elos B2 Field Notte, which offers great value for money, is suited to fieldwork or clays and is future-proofed for use with steel in all choke constrictions

time-read
5 mins  |
December 2020
CALL OF THE WILD
Sporting Shooter

CALL OF THE WILD

Dom Holtam reconnects with one of the purest forms of shotgun shooting as he walks-up woodcock over pointing dogs in the Scottish Highlands

time-read
8 mins  |
December 2020
A yen for the Fens
Sporting Shooter

A yen for the Fens

Tony Jackson recounts a memorable duck flight over an area of Fenland in Norfolk with his friend and author, the late Alan Savory

time-read
4 mins  |
December 2020