Company Liquidation Laws Unfair
Noseweek|March 2019

Public Protector orders liquidation law reforms – thanks to a dispute between some pretty shady characters.

Jonathan Erasmus
Company Liquidation Laws Unfair

ON 19 DECEMBER 2018 PUBLIC Protector, advocate Busisiwe Mkhwebane released a report which requires changes to the regulations that determine how liquidators of insolvent companies are chosen and appointed, the time frames for this to happen and, importantly, the methods by which they can be removed from office.

Mkhwebane came to her ruling thanks to (1) a BEE junior coal miner, (2) a convicted child pornographer and a disbarred solicitor-turned-thieving banker-turned-unscrupulous-miner; and (3) a liquidator best known for saying “I looove money”.

Notably, she put an end to the “48-hour notice rule” as she found it “unfair, unjust to creditors and susceptible to abuse by (drum roll) …unscrupulous lawyers and liquidators”.

The rule, as explained to Noseweek by CEO of the South African Restructuring and Insolvency Practitioners’ Association René Bekker, gives creditors just two days or 48 hours, to file their claims against a company being placed under provisional liquidation – that’s assuming the creditors all knew about the pending liquidation. If you are an ordinary run-of-the-mill creditor, it is most unlikely that you would have known in time to file your claim and attend that vital meeting of creditors where the provisional liquidators are nominated and elected.

The creditor with the biggest claim gets pro-rata the most votes. Unless you are in on a privately arranged prior deal between a group of creditors in the know, the creditor that swings it is almost invariably a bank – which is as likely the liquidating creditor in control of events. The fact is, in the majority of cases a bank gets to nominate and elect its favoured liquidator who is likely to prefer the bank’s interests (and the bank’s lawyers’ interests), with little regard for those of lesser creditors.

This story is from the March 2019 edition of Noseweek.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the March 2019 edition of Noseweek.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM NOSEWEEKView All
Lennie The Liquidator Faces R500,000 Defamation Suit
Noseweek

Lennie The Liquidator Faces R500,000 Defamation Suit

After losing his cool when his fees were questioned

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 2020
Panel Beater De Luxe
Noseweek

Panel Beater De Luxe

Danmar Autobody and its erstwhile directors get a serious panel beating in court papers. Corruption and theft are said to have destroyed the firm chaired by Nelson Mandela’s eldest daughter, leaving 200 workers destitute and threatening to kill.

time-read
8 mins  |
September 2020
Meet Covid Diarist Ronald Wohlman
Noseweek

Meet Covid Diarist Ronald Wohlman

Ronald Wohlman – EX SOUTH African copywriter, author, and actor – never dreamt that his lockdown diaries, written on Facebook and followed by people all over the world – would become his “life’s work”.

time-read
10+ mins  |
September 2020
A Picture Of Peace?
Noseweek

A Picture Of Peace?

Beware: Appearances can be deceptive

time-read
6 mins  |
September 2020
Flogging A (Battery-Driven) Dead Horse
Noseweek

Flogging A (Battery-Driven) Dead Horse

Why plug-in vehicles are not all they’re cracked up to be– and, likely, never will be

time-read
4 mins  |
September 2020
Everybody Drinks Corona
Noseweek

Everybody Drinks Corona

I am hesitant to go Into the pub today. Not because it’s illegal, but there is a crème colored 1985 Mercedes 300D parked behind the pine tree. This means the devil is inside; that’s what we call Dr. De Villiers. You don’t know whether you will encounter the good doctor with the charming bedside manner or the violent, bipolar bully. The problem is, most of the time, you can never be sure which it is, so it’s best to always keep a social distance.

time-read
3 mins  |
May 2020
Never Take A Hypochondriac To A Pandemic
Noseweek

Never Take A Hypochondriac To A Pandemic

From Ronald Wohlman’s New York Corona Diary

time-read
4 mins  |
May 2020
The money train
Noseweek

The money train

Transnet in court battle with liquidators of Gupta-linked audit firm over R57m in ‘corrupt’ payments and invoices

time-read
10+ mins  |
May 2020
‘He's no pharmaceutical genius, he's a vulture'
Noseweek

‘He's no pharmaceutical genius, he's a vulture'

Pharma con seeks prison release to ‘help find Covid cure’

time-read
8 mins  |
May 2020
Bush school – A memoir
Noseweek

Bush school – A memoir

OUR SCHOOL WAS IN THE MIDDLE of the bush, ten miles from the nearest town in the harsh beauty of the Zimbabwean highveld. It started life in World War II as No 26 EFTS Guinea Fowl, a Royal Air Force elementary flying training school and I arrived there in 1954, just seven years after it became an all-white co-ed state boarding school.

time-read
10+ mins  |
May 2020