A Case For Downsizing

A smaller lure may be the trick to get reluctant muskies to commit

- Joe Bucher

While the majority of the musky industry seems to be focused lately on the concept of “bigger is better,” my experiences suggest the opposite approach might be the answer to fishless days. Admittedly, it took a major shoulder injury a few seasons ago to move me from the conventional wisdom of large lures, but the results have been astounding. I am now convinced that a smaller presentation actually triggers more strikes as well as plenty of lunkers.

I am not suggesting that big baits don’t have their place, nor am I denying large lures catch monster muskies consistently. In fact, there are clearly several situations demanding larger profile plugs. The most notable example I can think of is when you encounter spots loaded with “hammerhandle” northern pike. Launching a small, 5- to 7-inch lure over any pike-infested spot is sure to keep you busy unhooking the pesky critters.

Some other notable applications for outsized baits are for fishing in dark, turbid waters, and at night. Generally, larger profile lures help big fish zero-in on the target when there is diminished light or visibility. Clear water muskies in peak hot weather occasionally respond more aggressively to extra-large lures retrieved or trolled at extreme speeds. Yet, my experiences now suggest that downsizing, coupled with high speed, can also trigger these same fish. Finally, there are just those instances when your goal is to simply tap into the largest fish in the system and bypass everything else. Super-sizing your lure profile works for all species.