![Two Landmark Supreme Court Judgements Two Landmark Supreme Court Judgements](https://cdn.magzter.com/Business Today/1702113197/articles/kk-syYGk91702284063126/TWO-LANDMARK-SUPREME-COURT-JUDGEMENTS.jpg)
THE SUPREME COURT recently delivered two landmark judgements that will have ramifications for taxpayers. The first is whether licence fees paid by telecom operators are capital or revenue expenditure. The second concerns the Most Favoured Nation (MFN) clause that appears in the Double Taxation Avoidance Agreements entered into by India.
In the case of licence fees, the issue was whether the revenue share telecom operators paid to the government was capital expenditure. The operators were granted licences under the National Telecom Policy of 1994. It had two components: a lump sum and an amount calculated depending on the number of subscribers. Telecom operators had accepted that the payment of such licence fees was a capital expenditure under the Income Tax Act (I-T Act), 1961, which could be amortised under Section 35ABB of the I-T Act.
In 1999, the government came out with a new policy under which telecom operators could pay a revenue share computed as a percentage of their annual gross revenues (AGR), if they had paid lump sum fees under the old policy until August 1999.
Telecom operators contended that revenue share paid constituted revenue expenditure, which was tax deductible. The tax authorities treated it as capital expenditure covered by Section 35ABB of the I-T Act. The operators' contention was upheld by the Commissioner (Appeals), the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal, and the Delhi High Court. The revenue department carried the matter to the Supreme Court. Apart from the Delhi High Court, the Bombay High Court and the Karnataka High Court, too, held it as revenue expenditure.
This story is from the December 24, 2023 edition of Business Today India.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the December 24, 2023 edition of Business Today India.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
!["IF ANYONE WANTS TO INVEST, COME TO HYDERABAD" "IF ANYONE WANTS TO INVEST, COME TO HYDERABAD"](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/8UUmdBKhG1739360774339/IF-ANYONE-WANTS-TO-INVEST-COME-TO-HYDERABAD.jpg)
"IF ANYONE WANTS TO INVEST, COME TO HYDERABAD"
Telangana CM Revanth Reddy's global ambitions, AI, green energy, and how Hyderabad is positioning itself as a premier business and innovation hub
![Where Food Meets Magic Where Food Meets Magic](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/opsS-DWVa1739361048657/WHERE-FOOD-MEETS-MAGIC.jpg)
Where Food Meets Magic
THE FOOD AT THE ROCA BROTHERS' RESTAURANT IN GIRONA TRANSCENDS THE ORDINARY TO BECOME PURE MAGIC
!["INDIA SHOULD CONSIDER LAND POOLING MODEL" "INDIA SHOULD CONSIDER LAND POOLING MODEL"](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/O3hMkV8Ix1739360926098/INDIA-SHOULD-CONSIDER-LAND-POOLING-MODEL.jpg)
"INDIA SHOULD CONSIDER LAND POOLING MODEL"
Andhra Pradesh (AP) minister Nara Lokesh talks about what governments can learn from the state about overcoming the land availability challenge
![Breaking Barriers: The Extraordinary Journey of Pulkit Prakash Breaking Barriers: The Extraordinary Journey of Pulkit Prakash](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/Qezwx8vm31739359443032/BREAKING-BARRIERS-THE-EXTRAORDINARY-JOURNEY-OF-PULKIT-PRAKASH.jpg)
Breaking Barriers: The Extraordinary Journey of Pulkit Prakash
In an era where success often seems predetermined by privilege, Pulkit Prakash's journey from modest beginnings to legal eminence challenges conventional narratives. His remarkable transformation into the founding partner of Niti Bodh, a prestigious law firm, demonstrates how unwavering determination can reshape destinies.
!["Keep the company's imperatives in mind first" "Keep the company's imperatives in mind first"](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/aJUXQY6NA1739361504276/KEEP-THE-COMPANYS-IMPERATIVES-IN-MIND-FIRST.jpg)
"Keep the company's imperatives in mind first"
Westlife Foodworld Limited is a fast food restaurant holding company
![Beyond the Scalpel: How Dr. Unmesh Takalkar Revolutionized Healthcare in Central Maharashtra Beyond the Scalpel: How Dr. Unmesh Takalkar Revolutionized Healthcare in Central Maharashtra](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/FplI5Ms8N1739359551054/BEYOND-THE-SCALPEL-HOW-DR-UNMESH-TAKALKAR-REVOLUTIONIZED-HEALTHCARE-IN-CENTRAL-MAHARASHTRA.jpg)
Beyond the Scalpel: How Dr. Unmesh Takalkar Revolutionized Healthcare in Central Maharashtra
In an era where medical excellence often leads to overseas opportunities, one doctor chose a different path - transforming his homeland's healthcare landscape instead of seeking personal fortune abroad. Dr. Unmesh Vidyadhar Takalkar's journey from a bright medical student to a pioneering healthcare visionary in Marathwada stands as a testament to the power of purpose-driven leadership.
!["Fils WILL MAKE A COMEBACK, MAYBE THIS YEAR" "Fils WILL MAKE A COMEBACK, MAYBE THIS YEAR"](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/kNugpgta61739359820916/FILS-WILL-MAKE-A-COMEBACK-MAYBE-THIS-YEAR.jpg)
"Fils WILL MAKE A COMEBACK, MAYBE THIS YEAR"
Veteran investor Madhusudan Kela, Founder of MK Ventures, on Union Budget 2025-26, the future trajectory of the market, the Indian economy and more
!["TAX CUT TO PUT MONEY INTO PEOPLES' HANDS" "TAX CUT TO PUT MONEY INTO PEOPLES' HANDS"](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/QdGfNhHaG1739357229548/TAX-CUT-TO-PUT-MONEY-INTO-PEOPLES-HANDS.jpg)
"TAX CUT TO PUT MONEY INTO PEOPLES' HANDS"
Tuhin Kanta Pandey, Finance and Revenue Secretary, and Arunish Chawla, Secretary of DIPAM, explain the macro philosophy of the Budget
![A BONANZA FOR THE MIDDLE CLASS A BONANZA FOR THE MIDDLE CLASS](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/2ZNaJpiz81739356393308/A-BONANZA-FOR-THE-MIDDLE-CLASS.jpg)
A BONANZA FOR THE MIDDLE CLASS
THE GOVERNMENT INCREASED THE TAX EXEMPTION LIMIT TO 12 LAKH AND REVISED RATES LOWER UNDER THE NEW TAX REGIME IN THE BUDGET FOR FY26. WITH A NEW INCOME TAX BILL ON THE WAY, WHAT DO THE MEASURES MEAN FOR TAXPAYERS?
![Expect Private Investment Cycle To Pick Up Expect Private Investment Cycle To Pick Up](https://reseuro.magzter.com/100x125/articles/161/1991162/NrxVnTuxi1739359720957/EXPECT-PRIVATE-INVESTMENT-CYCLE-TO-PICK-UP.jpg)
Expect Private Investment Cycle To Pick Up
The government's budgetary strategy focusses on modification and moderation, a fine balance between the long term and the short term