The Second World War saw grand military strategy play out on the largest scale ever seen, stretching across most of the globe. Shaping this complex strategic situation were what historian Phillips O’Brien calls “The Five”: Winston Churchill, Adolf Hitler, Joseph Stalin, Benito Mussolini and Franklin D Roosevelt.
In The Strategists, O’Brien rejects the prevailing view among his contemporaries to argue that Second World War strategy was individualistic, shaped by the idiosyncrasies of these individuals. Laying out each leader’s experience of the First World War, the interwar period and their ascendency to power, O’Brien paints a vivid picture of how their wartime character and decision-making was formed.
O’Brien spoke with History of War to discuss each of The Five’s background and character, and how that translated into the way they led their nation’s grand strategy. He then considers how the Allied ‘Big Three’ (Roosevelt, Churchill and Stalin) began to butt heads as the war came to an end and the post-war world began to take shape. He also shares his thoughts on how the Russo-Ukraine War shows that flawed individuals can still hijack grand strategy.
How do you compare and contrast each of The Five’s upbringings, as well as their participation (or not) in the First World War?
The Five come in two categories. First, you can call them the aristocrats – Churchill and Roosevelt – who came from very privileged backgrounds. People sometimes say Churchill didn’t have much money, but his family had enormous social capital. Roosevelt was very much the same way. He came from an elite northeast family, raised in a life of great wealth. What it gave them was confidence that the others gained through war experience.
This story is from the Issue 137 edition of History of War.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the Issue 137 edition of History of War.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
COUPS & CHAOS
How the French armed forces lost the war in Algeria and almost destroyed French democracy in the process
BATTLE OF ALGIERS
When the Front de libération nationale FLN) took its war to the streets of the capital, France’s military responded with merciless wrath
THE RISE OF ALGERIAN RESISTANCE
How the anti-colonialist struggle around the globe helped inspire Algeria’s liberation movement to organise and fight back
ROOTS OF REVOLUTION
A century of French occupation led to a genocide in Algeria that provoked one of the bloodiest showdowns of the modern age
DWIGHT W BIRDWELL
In the opening hours of the North Vietnamese Tet Offensive, this Specialist Five led his armoured cavalry detachment in repulsing a fierce communist assault against Tan Son Nhut Air Base near Saigon
THE FIVE STRATEGY AND LEADERSHIP
Phillips O’Brien discusses how this quintet of national leaders impacted the course of the Second World War
Great Battles FLODDEN
On the morning of 9 September 1513, King James lV of Scotland stood atop Flodden Hill with what seemed an insurmountable advantage over the English. Yet by the day's end he would lay slain and his army shattered
FERDINAND 'THE BLOODY'
Known for his brutal martial punishment and execution of his own men, Ferdinand Schérner’s ruthlessness was matched only by his devotion to Nazi ideology
AIRBORNE UNDER SIEGE ARNHEM
For nine days the heroic 1st Airborne fought desperately, waiting vainly for relief that never came
SCANDINAVIA UNDER ATTACK
Hitler’s forces smash through Denmark and Norway ina grim foretaste of the terrible fate awaiting the rest of Western Europe
