The problem with provenance
The Field|July 2023
Collectors love a good story and will often pay a premium for genuine, authenticated items. But as Roger Field explains, provenances can be frustratingly difficult to verify and just as tough to disprove
Roger Field
The problem with provenance

PROVENANCE, provenance, provenance. This collecting phrase might have much the same ring and price-boosting effect on antiques and collectables as property's much-quoted location, location, location' but, unlike the latter, it comes with various caveats. Before you start quibbling, today's brilliant location is not in itself a guarantee of future perfection, as all it takes is the tap of a planning officer's e-signature to transform a location' plus into a blighted minus as a new road or housing development is plonked outside your back door. But try as sellers might to obfuscate and dissemble in their sales particulars, it is blinking obvious come viewing day if a property is in a great location, and worth a lot more, or not.

Provenances can be more complex, not least as the ungodly have been faking them to boost values for as long as they have been faking antiques themselves. The ancient Greeks merrily carved statues purportedly made by even more ancient Greeks to sell to their new Roman masters. I can picture an ancient Roman Del Boy cheerfully 'up-pricing' a bit of gaudy jewellery to a gullible-looking customer: "Honest guv, this was taken off that strumpet Cleopatra's body just after the snake got her. My life on it! This knife was used to kill Caesar." And, after a couple of generations of repetition, risible tosh morphs into value-enhancing history.

That's the problem with some provenances: they can be infuriatingly difficult to verify and just as hard to disprove. And we want to believe them as we all love a great story. Collectors will happily pay to add multiple zeroes to the price because Eric Clapton (genuinely) played on this guitar at that concert. Or for that particular sword that was no ifs, no buts used at Waterloo. That is where I am taking you next.

Bu hikaye The Field dergisinin July 2023 sayısından alınmıştır.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

Bu hikaye The Field dergisinin July 2023 sayısından alınmıştır.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

THE FIELD DERGISINDEN DAHA FAZLA HIKAYETümünü görüntüle
Helping hot dogs chill out
The Field

Helping hot dogs chill out

From cool coats to clippers, there are a whole host of ways to keep your canine companion comfortable as the summer heat intensifies, says David Tomlinson

time-read
4 dak  |
July 2024
Art in the field
The Field

Art in the field

Sculpting his wild subjects from life, Fred Gordon is breaking new ground in bronze, says Janet Menzies

time-read
3 dak  |
July 2024
How to canapé
The Field

How to canapé

A summer celebration is nothing without these tiny works of art. Devised by the country's best canapé cooks, they are just the thing to make your party swing

time-read
5 dak  |
July 2024
Ginger-beer childhoods
The Field

Ginger-beer childhoods

Summer holidays filled with outdoor adventures are the perfect way to foster a love of the countryside and a lifetime enthusiasm for the field

time-read
6 dak  |
July 2024
Glamour, intelligence and drive as standard
The Field

Glamour, intelligence and drive as standard

Retrieving birds with pace, energy and undeniable elan, these sporting poodles are winning over even traditional gundog breed enthusiasts

time-read
7 dak  |
July 2024
The cycle begins
The Field

The cycle begins

Though it may lie forgotten for much of the year, the kennel bicycle is indispensable in summer when hound exercise gets under way

time-read
7 dak  |
July 2024
Turning the tide on the Tyne
The Field

Turning the tide on the Tyne

The industrial age brought prosperity to Newcastle but at great cost to the Tyne and its salmon. Today its waters are a haven for fish and anglers alike

time-read
7 dak  |
July 2024
En garde: a guide to fencing
The Field

En garde: a guide to fencing

Not just a clash of swords and some fancy footwork, this ancient sport is an art form that demands agility, discipline and control

time-read
7 dak  |
July 2024
Who was Baron Pierre de Coubertin?
The Field

Who was Baron Pierre de Coubertin?

It was a diminutive, 19th-century French aristocrat, Baron Pierre de Coubertin (pictured, left), who came up with the idea of reviving the Olympic Games while studying in Paris. He was a sporting sort himself, and had also long despaired of what he perceived as French degeneracy; his country had been humiliated by the loss of the Franco-Prussian War and he attributed this to his countrymen's lack of moral fibre.

time-read
3 dak  |
July 2024
A gold-medal guide to Olympic shooting
The Field

A gold-medal guide to Olympic shooting

Everything you need to know, from history, disciplines, rules and regulations to the British sportsmen and women striving for glory

time-read
10+ dak  |
July 2024