The World Health Organization (WHO) recently came out against artificial sweeteners. This provoked widespread hysteria. It did not conduct any new research. It issued a general statement based, it said, on an examination of around 280 older studies. By rereading these studies, the folks at WHO had concluded that sweeteners did not contribute to weight loss.
This was interesting but hardly surprising. A sweetener is not a diet pill. Nobody takes it thinking it will suddenly cause weight loss.
But sugar, medical research has demonstrated, does cause weight gain. So people use sweeteners to reduce their dependence on sugar. Therefore, they avoid the weight gain that would otherwise be caused by the consumption of sugar.
Besides, many of those who use sweeteners are diabetic or pre-diabetic. The weight gain/ weight loss argument is peripheral for them. Should they also give up sweeteners?
WHO suggests they should. Should they go back to sugar? No, that's bad too. What should they do? Well, according to WHO and some of the doctors quoted, they should just give up eating sweet things. Ok, maybe they can eat some fruit.
Is this realistic?
It is possible to argue that we should cut back on sweets, but foolish and unrealistic to say that we should all give them up completely.
Once you accept that, then it comes down to a simple question: Which is less harmful? Sugar or sweetener.
This story is from the May 27, 2023 edition of Brunch.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the May 27, 2023 edition of Brunch.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Let's tri all the angles
BFFs falling for the same girl, kidnap twists, murders, bromances. These 10 three-way love stories play with geometry and our feelings
Should you Q up for this?
Audi's luxury SUV, the Q8, has had a refresh. But a sleeker grille and headlight tech don't make up for what's still missing
How to plan a great escape
It's getting colder. It's already hard to breathe. Why not plan a winter vacation that's a world away but not too far away?
Kababs, yes, but khandvi too
Mughlai cuisine has as many vegetarian dishes as meaty ones. A new translation of a 16th century manuscript shows how we ate, and why modern labels are pointless
I can be your hero
Gurfateh Pirzada, only afewroles old, is the green flag we didn't know we needed. He's learning from women. He wants to be more thana lover and a fighter. He's hoping we all do better. No wonder everyone's crushing on him
Meet the export experts
Khadi crop-tops in Spain, faux-leather hoodies in London, fairytale wedding gowns in the UAE. See how some desi labels are killing it on foreign shores
Why we're all feeling Blue
Coco Mellors's new novel is about grief, sisterhood, and of course, addiction and unlikeable women. How does she make it work?
This week, we're...
Changing the momo game, listening to kids, starting a new business, and supporting pro waxxers
Rohit Chawla
Photographer, artist, @RohitChawlaPhotography_
Congratulations, it's a goal
Lakeside vows, pastel palettes, bayous, backyards and boats. These celeb weddings are what modern fairytales are made of