ANTI-DEFECTION LAW HAS PROVED TO BE A COMPLETE FAILURE
THE WEEK India|October 06, 2024
P. CHIDAMBARAM WAS A first-time MP when the anti-defection law was passed in Parliament in 1985.
SONI MISHRA
ANTI-DEFECTION LAW HAS PROVED TO BE A COMPLETE FAILURE

He walked up to A.K. Sen, the law minister, and suggested that he should carefully consider the provisions being made in the Tenth Schedule. Sen’s reply, said Chidambaram, was that it could be amended later.

Forty years later, the Congress in its manifesto for the Lok Sabha elections promised to amend the law. Chidambaram, the chief architect of the manifesto and one of the brightest legal minds in India, insists that an amendment should make defection a ground for automatic disqualification and ban the member from contesting an election during the term of the house. Excerpts from an interview:

Q/ A Congress government enacted the anti-defection law in 1985. Before the Lok Sabha elections this year, the Congress, in its manifesto, said the law must be amended. Why do you feel the law needs to be amended?
A/ I remember the year in which the Tenth Schedule was passed in Parliament. A.K. Sen, who was the law minister, had moved the bill. I was a first-term member of Parliament, and I walked up to him and said, ‘Sir, I think you should carefully consider the provisions you are making in the Tenth Schedule’. He said, ‘Let’s pass it, and then we can always amend it’.

The original Tenth Schedule had a provision for split and merger. The provision for split was omitted by an amendment, but the provision for merger remains. And that has been open to abuse. The provision for merger encourages one or more members who are elected on a party ticket to defect from the party and then put forward various arguments. The provision for merger, on many occasions, effectively becomes a split in the legislature party. The matter then goes to the speaker, who sits on the complaint for months, in some cases, years. He hands down a decision towards the end of the term of the member, and in many cases, after the term of the member is over.

This story is from the October 06, 2024 edition of THE WEEK India.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the October 06, 2024 edition of THE WEEK India.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM THE WEEK INDIAView All
War Over Wounded Earth
THE WEEK India

War Over Wounded Earth

For the BJP andthe Congress, the ravaged farmlands of Vidarbha represent a cxitieal battleground in their larger struggle to win Maharashtra

time-read
9 mins  |
November 10, 2024
Say no to continual elections
THE WEEK India

Say no to continual elections

Following the recommendations of a high-level committee led by former president Ram Nath Kovind to streamline the widely scattered schedule of national, state and local elections, the Union cabinet has reportedly approved two constitutional amendment bills for likely introduction in Parliament. Predictably, the return of the ‘one nation, one election’ issue to news has set off a flurry of objections by several opposition leaders.

time-read
2 mins  |
November 10, 2024
Fabulously, fashionably funny
THE WEEK India

Fabulously, fashionably funny

The third season of the Karan Johar-produced Fabulous Lives of Bollywood Wives dropped on Netflix, but articles criticising the show appear in some news site or the other almost daily. If it is so bad, why keep writing about it? And if it is so bad, why would the superpowers at Netflix, who are harder to meet than the prime minister, commission the show season after season?

time-read
2 mins  |
November 10, 2024
All in the family
THE WEEK India

All in the family

The Chitaras have been passing down the secret art of Mata Ni Pachedi through generations for more than 400 years now

time-read
6 mins  |
November 10, 2024
Raise a toast to Vidya Balan
THE WEEK India

Raise a toast to Vidya Balan

Vidya Balan is a New Year baby. At 45, she is aglow in the most beautiful way, having won the hearts and admiration of countless fans across the world, who watched the supremely talented actor take a public tumble on stage at a high-profile promotional event recently, sharing the platform with no less a dancer than the eternally graceful Madhuri Dixit.

time-read
2 mins  |
November 10, 2024
Death no bar
THE WEEK India

Death no bar

Being alive is not a legal requirement to be elected president of the United States

time-read
2 mins  |
November 10, 2024
The Lotus POTUS
THE WEEK India

The Lotus POTUS

You should visit us one of these days— there is so much excitement in our USA! No, I don’t mean the famous USA—the Ulhasnagar Sindhi Association of Mumbai.

time-read
3 mins  |
November 10, 2024
RAY OF HOPE
THE WEEK India

RAY OF HOPE

Actor and cancer survivor Lisa Ray talks to oncologist Dr Jame Abraham about inner strength and her surrogacy journey

time-read
5 mins  |
November 10, 2024
LEVERAGE AI TO ENHANCE WORK
THE WEEK India

LEVERAGE AI TO ENHANCE WORK

AT THE WEEK Health Summit, Siddharth Bagga, head (retail, CPG and health care), Google Cloud, elaborated on the significant work that Google has been doing in health care through artificial intelligence (AI).

time-read
2 mins  |
November 10, 2024
PRESSURE POINTS
THE WEEK India

PRESSURE POINTS

Author and MP Shashi Tharoor and motivational speaker Gaur Gopal Das on how to find healing and meaning in today's world

time-read
2 mins  |
November 10, 2024