NEW DELHI:
The court held that the July 7, 2008 decision of the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission (NCDRC) lacked the jurisdiction to deal with a matter which was a private contract entered between the credit card user and banks. Credit card holders are largely educated people who are aware of their obligations of timely payment and penalty in the case of delay, the top court said. The discretion to levy the quantum of interest was left to the banks by the Reserve Bank of India (RBI), the statutory authority that regulates banking business.
The court ruled that the NCDRC judgment to be unsustainable on three fronts - law, policy and contract.
Though the commission's order was not in force after a stay by the top court in February 2009, the court's decision must be understood in the context of how the case came up before the commission, the arguments made by RBI and banks, and the statutory framework that governs the case in hand.
'No unfair practice' The case before NCDRC was filed by two NGOs - Awaz and Jagrut Nagrik -in a representative capacity based on an illustrative case of a man named Pradeep Thakur, a credit card holder with Citibank, against whom a claim of ₹90,000 was levied towards excess interest by the bank.
The two NGOs claimed that banks in general are charging credit card users interest at the rates of 36% to 49% per annum for defaulting on timely payment. They argued that, on the face of it, such excessive interest is usurious and RBI has not acted despite receiving several complaints. It was further argued that considering the prime lending rates fixed by various banks, RBI must issue a circular directing that interest rates should not be unreasonable.
This story is from the December 25, 2024 edition of Hindustan Times Thane.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the December 25, 2024 edition of Hindustan Times Thane.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
Khel Ratna row: Manu says lapse on my part
Seeking to end all \"speculations\" after her name was not considered for the Khel Ratna Award, Paris Olympics double medallist shooter Manu Bhaker on Tuesday admitted to a possible lapse in her application for the country's top sports award.
Paris heartache over, Chanu focuses on regaining fitness
The right thigh is still a work in progress for her. She can win a medal anywhere in the world if she is injury free. VIJAY SHARMA, National weightlifting coach
EX-INDIA BATTER KAMBLI STABLE, RECOVERING WELL
Former India cricketer Vinod Kambli is stable and recovering after being admitted in a private hospital in Thane, doctors and sources close to the former dashing player from Mumbai said on Tuesday.
Rohit's mantra: A personalised approach is key
Captaincy demands a mindset as varied as the individuals in the squad. You need to know when to be sympathetic and when to have a stern word or two.
Konstas to debut; Head, Rohit ready to go
Much of the intrigue on Tuesday centred around the fitness of two key figures on either side—Australia's Travid Head and India's Rohit Sharma.
INDIA NAME U-19 WOMEN'S T20 WC SQUAD, HOPE FOR TITLE DEFENCE
The Indian women's cricket team has so far been unsuccessful in winning a World Cup, not even after the big boost of coming under the BCCI fold in 2006. The chances of India defending the women's T20 U-19 World Cup, to be held in Malaysia from January 18 to February 2 though is high.
Harleen Deol, Pratika Rawal shine as India women clinch ODI series
It was a thoroughly dominant all-round performance from India yet again in this series as they defeated West Indies by 115 runs in the second women's ODI and took a 2-0 lead in the three-match series at the Kotambi Stadium, Vadodara on Tuesday.
Rupee hits record low for sixth straight session
The Indian rupee weakened to its all-time low for the sixth consecutive trading session on Tuesday as a rise in U.S. bond yields boosted the dollar and strong demand for the greenback from importers added to the lingering pressure on the local currency.
Informal sector GVA up 16.5%, workers by 10%
The Indian economy had 73.4 million non-farm informal sector enterprises in 2023-24, according to data published by the National Statistics Office (NSO) on Tuesday.
HURT BY IMPORTS, STEELMAKERS EYE SAFEGUARD DUTY
The commerce ministry's investigation into imports of flat steel products and a likely safeguard duty to curb their shipments have sparked optimism of a turnaround for Indian steelmakers after a tepid year marred by slipping sales prices and shrinking margins.