The decision which came weeks after the Election Commission of India also ruled against NCP patriarch Sharad Pawar - is another jolt to the senior leader. Narwekar held that the test of legislative majority was decided in favour of Ajit Pawar after the other two grounds-party constitution and leadership structure -were found to be inconclusive.
The decision was similar to Narwekar's ruling in the Sena vs Sena case in January, where he also found in favour of chief minister Eknath Shinde but refused to disqualify lawmakers of either faction. The battle for both regional behemoths, the Sena and the NCP, is now likely to be decided in the Supreme Court.
"...I hold that the preliminary issue as to which faction is the real political party is discernible from the legislative majority, which existed when the rival factions emerged. Further I hold that the Ajit Pawar faction had an overwhelming legislative majority when the rival factions emerged," Narwekar said in a 22-page ruling.
The speaker who had been asked by the apex court to announce his decision by February 15- dismissed disqualification petitions filed by either faction, saying that the grounds mentioned did not fall under the jurisdiction of the 10th schedule of the Constitution that deals with the defection of elected representatives.
He, however, decided to reserve his verdict on the chief whip of the party, which is expected to come within a week.
The decision sparked a political controversy.
Sharad Pawar faction leader Jitendra Awhad called it a ridiculous judgment. "The assembly speaker Narwekar is playing the role of Dhritarashtra and has become shameless," he said.
This story is from the February 16, 2024 edition of Hindustan Times.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the February 16, 2024 edition of Hindustan Times.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
No legislative work as Parl deadlock persists
The first week of the winter session of Parliament saw the Lok Sabha sit for only 3% of its allotted time, with repeated disruptions related to the bribery charges levied by US prosecutors against the Adani Group, communal tension in Sambhal, and the recent violence in Manipur.
90 private members' bills set to be tabled
Over 90 private members' bills are set to be introduced in Parliament during the winter session, including key legislation to protect employees from artificial intelligence impacts and criminalise deepfakes.
Adani indictment 'legal matter' between pvt entities, US: MEA
India on Friday said the indictment of Indian tycoon Gautam Adani by US prosecutors is a \"legal matter\" involving private entities and individuals and the US Department of Justice, and the Indian side has not yet received any official request for cooperation.
Meitei group chief under NIA scanner
OF THE 8 CASES, NIA IS PROBING TWO AGAINST ARAMBAI TENGGOL LEADER KHUMAN
Oppn crushing the spirit of Constitution, says PM
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Friday hit out at the Opposition for \"misleading\" the country and crushing \"the spirit of the Constitution\", even as he credited Bharatiya Janata Party workers for the unprecedented mandate in Odisha, Haryana and Maharashtra.
CANCEL TUNGSTEN MINING IN TN DISTT, STALIN URGES MODI
Tamil Nadu chief minister MK Stalin on Friday wrote to Prime Minister Narendra Modi seeking the cancellation of rights granted by the Centre to a private firm to mine tungsten in Madurai district.
NO TREE-FELLING AT NIGHT IN DISTRICTS NEAR TAJ MAHAL: SC
The Supreme Court on Friday directed that no trees will be felled in the Taj Trapezium Zone (TTZ) between 6pm and 8am as it took up a \"shocking\" case of overnight felling of 454 trees in Mathura.
J&K SACKS 2 GOVT EMPLOYEES OVER 'TERROR LINKS'
The Jammu & Kashmir government on Friday terminated two government employees from service for their alleged involvement in anti-national activities and terror links, officials said.
Refusing to marry not abetment to suicide: SC
The Supreme Court on Friday ruled that a refusal to marry, even if preceded by a relationship or promises of marriage, cannot be construed as abetment to suicide under the penal law of the land.
Top court stays HC order restoring DA case against Panneerselvam, kin
The Supreme Court on Friday stayed the order of the Madras high court restoring corruption cases against former Tamil Nadu chief minister O Panneerselvam and his kin almost 12 years after he was discharged in the case in 2012.