While there are many lenses through which one might view the Supreme Court, the ultimate test of its success must be its legitimacy, its ability to command respect and compliance. By this standard, we must all be troubled by recent trends, now too frequent to be shrugged off as mere aberrations.
In one instance, a judge of the Punjab and Haryana High Court (HC) made sharply critical comments about an interim order of the Supreme Court. A five-judge bench of the Supreme Court was promptly constituted by then CJI Chandrachud, and the offending observations expunged. In another case, a judge of the Calcutta HC continued hearing a sensitive political matter after having been explicitly directed by the apex court to desist. In a third example, a Karnataka HC judge, while not addressing the Supreme Court directly, made remarks widely criticised as religiously insensitive and misogynistic.
In each of these cases, the Court has come down with a heavy hand, and self-consciously so. Five judge benches have been constituted to send a clear and unequivocal message. But in all of this, a deeper introspection is eschewed. Why are high court judges—constitutional functionaries themselves—so frequently thought to be disregarding the apex court's writ? Why do even final Supreme Court judgments so often seem like merely another page in the chapter, and not the definitive word they must ideally be understood to be?
Denne historien er fra November 12, 2024-utgaven av Hindustan Times.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent ? Logg på
Denne historien er fra November 12, 2024-utgaven av Hindustan Times.
Start din 7-dagers gratis prøveperiode på Magzter GOLD for å få tilgang til tusenvis av utvalgte premiumhistorier og 9000+ magasiner og aviser.
Allerede abonnent? Logg på
Have to be ready to take a few blows: Pujara
Marnus Labuschagne wants to \"pull off a Pujara\".
Amid rising pollution, EV sales fall off a cliff in Delhi
No incentive, won't buy. That appears to be the message coming through from dismayed consumers in Delhi after the state government failed to renew road tax and registration benefits on electric cars and two wheelers this September.
India, UK can look at tech collaboration in Al: Goyal
India and the UK can have a technological collaboration in areas such as artificial intelligence learnings, telemedicine, climate modelling, precision farming and organic chemicals, commerce minister Piyush Goyal on Thursday said.
KENYA DROPS AIRPORT DEAL WITH ADANI AFTER US INDICTMENTS
Kenyan President William Ruto said on Thursday he had ordered the cancellation of a procurement process that had been expected to award control of the country's main airport to India's Adani Group after its founder was indicted in the United States.
Adani's US indictment rocks group stocks and bonds alike
Investor sentiment shaken as charges against Adani led to market losses
New-look CPI may sport price data from e-c0mmerce
India may include e-commerce pricing data, among other items, ahead of setting a new base year to measure retail inflation as part of a broader initiative to better reflect contemporary consumer spending patterns.
US panel to Visit India in Mar, explore greater mkt access
An American delegation of small enterprises will visit India in March next year to explore greater market access for their products, which would be one of the first major US trade missions immediately after the Trump administration assumes power, two officials said.
Adani Green scraps $600 mn bond offering
THE ISSUE WAS OVER-SUBSCRIBED THREE TIMES. BUT FOLLOWING THE ALLEGATIONS, THE ISSUE WAS SCRAPPED
US government calls for breakup of Google and Chrome
The US government, late on Wednesday, asked a judge to order the dismantling of Google by selling its widely used Chrome browser in a major antitrust crackdown on the internet giant.
Matt Gaetz withdraws name as Trump's attorney general pick
Former Florida congressman Matt Gaetz has withdrawn as President-elect Donald Trump's pick for attorney general following scrutiny over a federal sex trafficking investigation.