'It's a brawl' Film explores story of art dealer forced by Nazis to sell collection
The Guardian|November 11, 2024
From the Benin bronzes to the Parthenon marbles, debates over the restitution of cultural artefacts are now a fact of life in an international art world forced to reckon with the often controversial history of its treasures.
Nadia Khomami
'It's a brawl' Film explores story of art dealer forced by Nazis to sell collection

From the Benin bronzes to the Parthenon marbles, debates over the restitution of cultural artifacts are now a fact of life in an international art world forced to reckon with the often controversial history of its treasures.

Museums around the world are having to consider the implications of retaining items many argue were taken from their owners under persecution or duress.

While many of the rows over restitution pertain to centuries-old pieces, the recovery of which is complicated by the time that has passed since their removal, a documentary shows how the fight to recover more modern artwork can be just as problematic.

The Spoils follows the continuing attempts to restitute the assets of a German-Jewish art dealer, drawing attention to how loaded a political and cultural issue restitution has become.

The film, which premieres in Britain as part of the Jewish film festival, follows two fraught restitution cases and two botched exhibitions attempting to honor Max Stern, who liquidated his Dusseldorf gallery in a Nazi-forced auction in 1937.

"The issues in the film go beyond the Holocaust and resonate with larger questions facing the art world right now," the film's director, Jamie Kastner, said.

"In recent years restitution has become an endlessly loaded political and cultural issue - be it over antiquities, colonial plunder, the Benin bronzes, the Parthenon marbles, or last week a Monet from Austria.

This story is from the November 11, 2024 edition of The Guardian.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

This story is from the November 11, 2024 edition of The Guardian.

Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.

MORE STORIES FROM THE GUARDIANView All
Rise lays bare the risks ahead for Labour
The Guardian

Rise lays bare the risks ahead for Labour

Any lingering hope that the Bank of England might deliver a pre-Christmas interest rate cut next month evaporated yesterday after official data showed inflation jumped to 2.3% in October.

time-read
1 min  |
November 21, 2024
'My way as a manager was taught by Bobby Robson'
The Guardian

'My way as a manager was taught by Bobby Robson'

George Burley is enjoying Ipswich's revival having reached great heights there more than 20 years ago

time-read
5 mins  |
November 21, 2024
Tuchel takes goalkeeping coach Hilario from Chelsea
The Guardian

Tuchel takes goalkeeping coach Hilario from Chelsea

Thomas Tuchel's backroom staff has been bolstered by the addition of Henrique Hilario, who is ending his 18-year association with Chelsea to become England JS new goalkeeping coach.

time-read
1 min  |
November 21, 2024
Kosovo to take Uefa to Cas after Romania awarded points
The Guardian

Kosovo to take Uefa to Cas after Romania awarded points

Kosovo are preparing an appeal to the court of arbitration for sport (Cas) after Uefa handed them a 3-O defeat for walking off the field during Friday's Nations League tie against Romania in Bucharest, which was eventually abandoned when they elected not to return.

time-read
1 min  |
November 21, 2024
Staying power No relegation break clause in Guardiola's new City contract
The Guardian

Staying power No relegation break clause in Guardiola's new City contract

Pep Guardiola's new one-year contract with Manchester City does not contain a break clause should the club be relegated from the Premier League if found guilty of financial wrongdoing by an independent commission.

time-read
1 min  |
November 21, 2024
Lopetegui's future to be decided in next two games
The Guardian

Lopetegui's future to be decided in next two games

Julen Lopetegui is facing two make-or-break games at West Ham, who have used the international break to explore potential replacements.

time-read
1 min  |
November 21, 2024
City's empire faces a set of challenges that will test Guardiola's genius
The Guardian

City's empire faces a set of challenges that will test Guardiola's genius

After signing deal, manager is left with an ageing squad as threat of Premier League punishment looms large

time-read
3 mins  |
November 21, 2024
The Guardian

Curry changing his technique to avoid more concussions

England are making changes to Tom Curry's all-action technique to ensure his safety after he returned to the fold for Sunday's clash with Japan following his latest concussion.

time-read
2 mins  |
November 21, 2024
Sacking me won't help Wales, insists Gatland in plea for patience
The Guardian

Sacking me won't help Wales, insists Gatland in plea for patience

The last rites, if that is what they are, are going to drag on a while longer yet. Warren Gatland has reiterated that he would resign as head coach if it were \"in the best interests of Welsh rugby\", while also making it Very clear that in his opinion it is not.

time-read
3 mins  |
November 21, 2024
Bronze takes 65 seconds to fire Chelsea into last eight
The Guardian

Bronze takes 65 seconds to fire Chelsea into last eight

Chelsea cruised into the knockout stages of the Champions League with two games to spare at Stamford Bridge.

time-read
2 mins  |
November 21, 2024