It was a result which extended the Pilgrims' unbeaten home league run to nine games but that will not have been any consolation to them after Sky Blues' defender Liam Kitching scored so late on.
Morgan Whittaker had put Argyle into a 56th-minute lead with his 18th goal of the season but Ellis Simms equalised for City soon afterwards.
The Pilgrims regained their advantage when Mickel Miller's angled shot deflected into the net off Coventry defender Bobby Thomas in the 68th minute and Ian Foster's side seemed poised to clinch an important win until the cruel, dramatic late twist.
Lino Sousa made his full debut for Argyle against the Sky Blues as one of three changes to the starting lineup from the 3-1 defeat away to Sunderland.
The 19-year-old loan signing from Aston Villa, who had previously played twice as a substitute for the Pilgrims, was at left wing-back in a 4-2-3-1 formation.
Also coming into the side were Matty Sorinola and Adam Randell, as Miller and Bali Mumba dropped down to the substitutes' bench and Adam Forhaw was ruled out by the knee injury he suffered at Sunderland.
Returning to the Argyle squad on the bench was Jordan Houghton, who had missed the previous four matches due to an ankle problem.
On a very misty, wet evening, the Pilgrims were again captained by Whittaker as they played their fourth game in only 12 days. Coventry had won six and drawn two of their previous nine league games so arrived at Home Park in very good form but it was Argyle who started the better.
Whittaker saw a lot of the ball in the opening exchanges and put in a dangerous low cross from the right which was scrambled clear by the Sky Blues.
This story is from the February 15, 2024 edition of The Herald.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the February 15, 2024 edition of The Herald.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
JOE BLOW FOR ARGYLE
CAPTAIN EDWARDS FACES A LONG SPELL ON THE SIDELINES
Buoyant Tavistock look to build on win at Mousehole
IT is one of those immutable clichés in football that 'anyone can beat anyone' in any particular league. But that is certainly the case in Southern League Division One South.
Mumba calls on team-mates to travel to Leeds believing that they can win
WING-BACK RELISHING CHANCE TO END POOR FORM AT ELLAND ROAD
Parkway aiming to build on home win
BUOYED by their first home league win of the season against Wimborne Town in midweek, Plymouth Parkway will be looking to make it two from two when they play host to Merthyr Town in the Southern League Premier Division tomorrow.
Tory contest over - but who has won?
KEMI Badenoch and Robert Jenrick's race to replace Rishi Sunak as Conservative Party leader has ended.
13,325 prisoners released under Tory scheme
MORE than 13,000 prisoners in England and Wales were released early under a scheme introduced by the previous Conservative government, new figures show.
Workload of NHS staff to rise - PM
THE NHS' workload is \"likely to go up, not down\", Sir Keir Starmer warned, as he hinted at reforms the Government might make to assist healthcare staff.
More flood victims fear
CREWS are searching for bodies in stranded cars and buildings following flash floods in Spain that claimed at least 140 lives.
Fundraiser for farewell to ‘gentle giant' Adrian
A MUCH-loved Plymouth doorman described as the \"gentlest\" bloke you'd ever meet has died at the age of 69.
Plan to raze empty buildings
BID TO REPLACE THEM WITH 'MUCH NEEDED' HOUSING