The psychologically impactful number of a million casualties was reported by The Wall Street Journal, whose reporting is generally regarded as accurate. The newspaper bases its figure on “a confidential Ukrainian estimate” earlier this year, which put the number of Ukrainian casualties at 80,000 dead and 400,000 wounded. It cites “Western intelligence” sources as estimating the number of Russian dead to be as high as 200,000, with 400,000 wounded.
However, Ukraine and Russia do not give out information about their respective military casualties, although each country has regularly floated purported numbers of dead and wounded on the enemy side; both Kyiv and Moscow have dismissed their opponents’ estimates as grossly inflated.
Even after visiting front lines and speaking to hundreds of ordinary soldiers, as well as junior and senior officers, it is impossible for anyone but a few at the top of the military and political leadership to know the true figures, and much less so for journalists, however experienced they might be in reporting from Ukraine’s battlefields.
Some Ukrainian officers and soldiers have told The Independent of horrific losses among their units. Several units told The Independent this year that only a handful out of a hundred of their comrades were left alive or fit to fight, while others talked of much lower casualty rates.
This story is from the September 19, 2024 edition of The Independent.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber ? Sign In
This story is from the September 19, 2024 edition of The Independent.
Start your 7-day Magzter GOLD free trial to access thousands of curated premium stories, and 9,000+ magazines and newspapers.
Already a subscriber? Sign In
The five UFC fights fans.most want to see in 2025
Jon Jones vs Tom Aspinall tops the wishlist for the year ahead
The many problems facing Tuchel as England manager
If 2024 took England to the brink of the trophy that has eluded them since 1966, 2025 brings the arrival of a manager with the track record of winning silverware that Gareth Southgate lacked.
Gunners fire back with win to stay in touch in title race
Arsenal scored two goals in three second-half minutes to complete a 3-1 comeback victory at Brentford to move back up to second in the Premier League.
TWIST AND DOUBT
Another cast of mild eccentrics enter the Traitors castle for a game of deception that's feeling familiar
The joke is over - get Mrs Brown's Boys off the BBC
As time goes on, Brendan O'Carroll's sitcom remains the same: tedious, small-minded and unfunny
'It felt way out of my depth'
Jim Swire's quest to find the truth behind the bombing of Pan Am flight 103 has inspired a new series starring Colin Firth. Ellie Harrison hears the actor's thoughts on the role
Love, the old-fashioned way
As many plan to swerve dating apps, Olivia Petter shares tips on how to hit on someone in real life - without being a creep
Which domestic routes are popular from Heathrow?
Q Which are the most popular domestic routes to and from London Heathrow?
How the keto diet's five-day meal plan can reboot your body and mind this January
Ready for a health reset? Hannah Twiggs learns about the benefits of keto and a new, easier approach to cutting carbs
CONNECTION LOST
Technology's complexity keeps growing and those showing us the way, such as Elon Musk, are now our leaders but what happens when innovation slows down, asks Andrew Griffin